Showing posts with label Alternative Medicine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alternative Medicine. Show all posts

Saturday, 14 July 2012

Abraham Kovoor’s Case Diary: The Curative Power of the Water of the River Ganges




Kerala, the land of my birth, is very similar to Lanka in its topography, climate, fauna flora and even the cultural and ethnic qualities of its peoples. The phonetics of the Malayalam language is more similar to the spoken Tamil of Jaffna than that of South India; yet, the morphology of the Malayalam alphabets is more similar to those of the Sinhala language than the Tamil. The industrious and adventurous nature with their thirst for education make Keralians more similar to the people of the North than those of the South in this country. But, in their social and domestic habits Keralians are more similar to the Sinhalese than the Tamils.

Like Ceylon, the chief products of Kerala are tea, rubber, coconut, paddy and spices. Kerala, like Ceylon, has a coconut-growing wet zone where the Malayalees live, and a palmyra-growing dry zone where the Tamils live. After India attained independence the palmyra country was merged with the Tamil Nadu. The present Kerala is the Malayalam-speaking coconut country formed by the merger of Malabar, Travancore and Cochin. The meaning of the word Kerala itself is the 'land of coconut’.

Devprayag: beginning of the Ganges proper
Courtesy: Wikipedia
The three main religious communities of Kerala arc the Hindus, the Syrian Christians, and the Moplah Muslims. They live happily as good neighbours, sharing many social customs in common.

As in Ceylon, witchcraft and devil dances thrive even to this day among the villagers in Kerala. More than half a century ago, when I was a young boy, it was a common practice to resort to witchcraft whenever anything untoward happened in the family. Most householders, as a result of superstitious beliefs, treasured some sort of' sacred' medicine or talisman which, they imagined, could affect magical cures for all their ailments. For the Nairs it was the 'sacred' water - theertham - from the holy river Ganges, brought by pilgrims who returned from the' sacred' city of Ben ares. For the Syrian Christians it was often the sanctified oil from Antioch or tile 'sacred' water from Lourdes. For the Moplahs it was the water sanctified by the container made to touch the 'sacred' Kaaba stone at Mecca brought yearly by the Haji pilgrims.

From 1921 to 24 my younger brother the late Dr. Behanan T. Kovoor of the Yale University, U. S., and I were students at the University of Calcutta. The city of Calcutta is about 1500 miles from my native town Tiruvalla. It took about five days for us to reach Calcutta by train.

A trip from Tiruvalla to the distant city on the banks of the river Ganges, by two young boys in search of higher education was an unusual event those days along the people of our neighbourhood. Because of the long distance and the heavy expense involved, we used to come home only once a year during the long mid-summer vacation.

Ceremonial Send-Off

Our departure to Calcutta after the holidays was a ceremonial affair. Days be­fore our departure, both my brother and I were feted by our neighbours. During the last few days of our holidays we had practically all our meals in the neighbouring houses irrespective of caste, creed or class. Almost all the Nair families wanted us to bring for them, when we returned at least a few drops of' theertham' (Ganges water). For them, we were extremely fortunate because even in our boyhood we would be getting a chance of bathing in the 'sacred' waters of the 'holy' Ganges, and thus attain 'moksha' without much effort.

A girl selling plastic containers
for carrying Ganges water, Haridwar.
Courtesy: Wikipedia
On the day of departure, our house and courtyard used to get crowded with men, women and children from the neighbouring houses. The men folks in our neighbourhood, who were mostly farmers and petty land-owners, kept away from their normal work that day for the sake of bidding us farewell.

After prayers and blessings by our family priest the Rev. K.P. Thomas, a beloved cousin of mine, our mother insisted that we went round to all the elderly men and women in the group to receive their blessings, which they did by placing their hands on our foreheads, with tears rolling down their cheeks. Many women used to burst out into loud weeping. The sympathetic effect of their weeping on our tender minds made us also shed tears. It was really a touching separation, the effect of which used to linger in our minds throughout the whole journey. Fortunately, on reaching Calcutta, the multifarious attractions of the big city, and the boisterous life in our hostel made us forget fast all about the home and our good neighbours. Such thoughts came back to our minds only when the time for our return trip approached during the next summer.

The Ganges

The river Ganges which has its source in the 'sacred' Kailas (Himalayas) flows down the Gangetic plain for about 1500 miles and falls into the Bay of Bengal. Calcutta is at the mouth of this river. It is in flood throughout the summer months when the snow on the Himalayas melts. Since it is a fast-flowing river, its water is always muddy.

During my long stay in Bengal I bathed in this river only once. It became my first and last bathe in that river because of a shocking experience I had on that occa­sion. As I lifted my head out of the water after a long immersion my head came in contact with a white and slimy object. It turned out to be a highly decomposed dis­membered human hand, partially eaten away by fish. It made me sick, and I had to go without food for a couple of days.

Though prohibited by law at present, during the days of my youth it was the usual practice among the Hindus of North India to ceremoniously deposit the dead bodies of their dear ones into the 'sacred' waters of this holy river. By this they insured 'moksha' for their departed souls. Those who lived far away from this river had to be satisfied by throwing the ashes into it after cremation. More than half a century ago one could see at any time numerous floating carcasses flowing down this river in various stages of decomposition. Thousands of dead bodies were dumped into this so-called sacred river every day at hundreds of cities, towns and villages along the banks of this long river. Yet, millions of pilgrims from allover India 'purify' themselves by not only bathing in it, but also by drinking the polluted water. I have seen devotees pushing away carcasses which come their way, and continue their ablu­tions. They were brainwashed from childhood into the belief that in spite of the pres­ence of decomposing carcasses in it, the water of the Ganges is pure and 'sacred'.

People wash laundry in the Ganges River
Courtesy: Science Daily
As a result of the abhorrence after my first nauseous experience in this 'holy' river, I decided not to take even a drop of water from it to my good neighbours. Since Behanan and I were reluctant to disappoint them, we decided to substitute some good well water for the Ganges water.

The nearest Railway Station to Tiruvalla those days was Kottarakkara. When we got down from the train at Kottarakkara we used to fill two bottles with drinking water from the filter in the waiting room, cork them properly and keep them along with our luggage. From that time onwards the water in the two bottles was called 'theertham' .

To reach Tiruvalla we had to travel about 56 miles by transport bus. There were many buses running on this route, all belonging to different operators. There was much rivalry and competition among those bus operators. This competition was a boon for the passengers as they received very polite and liberal treatments from them. As there was no governmental control over bus transport those days, buses came and went at unscheduled times, took whichever routes the driver liked, stopped whenever the passengers wanted, and cancelled trips according to the whims and fancies of the operators.

To make sure of their fare the conductors and cleaners of the few buses at the Kottarakkara Railway Station used to struggle among themselves to put the luggage of the waiting passengers on the hood of their own buses. Once the luggage was on the top of their bus, they were sure that the owner of the luggage would get into their bus.

When the conductors and cleaners handle our luggage roughly in their struggle to secure their fare, we used to 'beg them to be extra careful about the handling of the two bottles of 'theertham'. The word 'theertham' had an electrifying effect on them as well as the other fellow passengers. They handled the two bottles with due respect, and saw that both of us were given specially reserved seats by the side of the driver. Finally, on reaching Tiruvalla, the bus is diverted from the normal route with the sardine-packed passengers in it, and driven to an extra distance of about two miles to drop us at Kovoor house. After dropping our luggage and us at home the conductor produced a small phial with the humble request for a small quantity of the theertham to be shared among the driver, the cleaner, and himself.

Miracle Cures

We used to entrust the two bottles of theertham to our devoted Christian mother. With pride and pleasure she used to distribute the theertham to our Nair neighbours according to their needs. Till the death of our beloved mother in 1942 she was not told the real truth about the theertham. During the first two days of our arrival home, our neighbours used to flow in to greet us and to get their share of the sacred water.

Next mid-summer too the same fraud was repeated with all solemnity. Thus, for four consecutive years we continued to cheat our Christian mother and the Hindu neighbours with the Kottarakkara Railway Station water, and every holiday we had to give patient hearing to the numerous accounts of miraculous cures affected by the previous year's supply.

Puthur Raman Nair had this to say: "During the last two years we had no need to seek medical help. My mother had a severe attack of diarrhea last April. I just gave her a spoonful of honey with two drops of the theertham in it. That was all. Within three hours she was perfectly cured".

Kilannaparampil Lakshmi Amma said, "Every time my daughte,r got cold ot fever, a single drop of the theertham gave her perfect relief. I was wbject to severe migraine since I had a miscarriage three years ago. Now when I get any symptom of the head-ache coming on, I simply apply a drop of the theertham on my forehead and it stops with that. Even if it comes, the pain is only very slight."

Vettuvelil Parukutty who had two difficult and complicated childbirths when she gave birth to her first two children, had a very easy one at home when her third child was born. All what she did at the third time was to take two drops of the theertham immediately when the labour pain started.

Oliprakkatu Narayana Kuruppu proved the miraculous power of the theertham by an experimental research. He had two grafted mango trees in his garden. Both were of the same stock and of the same age. During the dry season he watered the two trees. Once he added a few drops of the theertham to the water he poured for one of the trees. When the flowering season arrived the tree which got a dose of the theertham flowered, while the other tree produced only a crop of tender leaves.

Chankroth Patchu Pillai immunised all the members of his family by pouring a spoonful of the theertham into the family well. Since taking this precaution not a single member of the Chankroth family fell ill.

There were numerous similar stories of miracles narrated by our neighbours who came to repeat their request for a further supply.

Explanation

The belief in miraculous powers of holy water is very ancient. Men in every walk and clime have maintained superstitious beliefs in the miraculous powers of sacred and holy objects, persons, places and times. Apart from the psychological effects of suggestion on their minds, there is absolutely no evidence to show that there are objective merits in such beliefs. Just as beneficial effects can be had by hypnotic suggestions, it is possible to have harmful effects, also by such suggestions or beliefs. Many of the neurotic subjects at mental hospitals are the final results of diverse types of superstitious beliefs. He who believes in sacredness is sure to get mentally tor­mented by acts of desecration too. Psychology tells us that such mental traumas are the causes of neurotic afflictions, mostly among the credulous and mentally feeble types. Among the numerous neurotics brought to me, I have found by statistics that the prevalence of neurosis among communities is directly proportional to the extent of superstitious beliefs held by them. Even in such communities, there are more women neurotics than men for the same reason. Better education for girls, and relaxation of the strict observance of the purdah, can help to a great extent to reduce neurosis among women.

A present Deputy Director of Education was some years ago teaching at Jaffna Central College, where I too was a teacher. One day he drank some water from a 'kooja' kept in the staff room. A few hours later another teacher drained the last quantity of water from that kooja into a glass tumbler. Out came a small dead snake along with the water. The Director who heard about it became violently sick. The nausea was continuous, and we got alarmed. Finally, it stopped abruptly when he was convinced that the water he drank was from another kooja which was on the same table. Though the water he drank was from the same kooja. His nausea stopped when he was made to believe blindly that he drank from another. This shows how one can get sick and get cured psychologically. But to argue that sickness which is not psycho­somatic in origin can be cured by faith is absurd.

The Kottarakkara Railway station water did not do any miracle in our neighbourhood. Our neighbours' anecdotes simply showed the credulous nature of those simple folks woo were brainwashed from childhood about the miraculous prop­erties of the theertham. Discarding logic and reason, their conditioned minds only attempted to give interpretations and explanations to suit their blind beliefs.

The so-called beneficial effects of sacrifices, pilgrimages, offerings, prayers, bless­ings, worships, vows, consecrations, dedications, ordinations, Lourdes water, theerthams, prasadhams, sacraments, baptism, anointing, holy ash, yagna, pooja etc., are of superstitious beliefs. He who believes in sacredness is sure to get mentally tor­mented by acts of desecration too. Psychology tells us that such mental traumas are the causes of neurotic afflictions, mostly among the credulous and mentally feeble types. Among the numerous neurotics brought to me, I have found by statistics that the prevalence of neurosis among communities is directly proportional to the extent of superstitious beliefs held by them. Even in such communities, there are more women neurotics than men for the same reason. Better education for girls, and relaxation of the strict observance of the purdah, can help to a great extent to reduce neurosis among women.

Academic education and intelligence need not be considered as marks of non-­gullibility. In fact, some of the highly educated persons in exalted positions are ex­tremely gullible, even resorting to witchcraft. It is only persons capable of rational thinking who can free themselves from credulity. Blind believers are mentally blind in spite of their intelligence and education.

Recently much newspaper publicity was given to the alleged healing power of one D.C. Wijemanne, who calls himself 'Uthama Sadhu'. Numerous persons, includ­ing an ex-cabinet minister, are reported to have gone to this man to get their diseases cured by being blessed by this man.

Like the Railway Station water, it was not the non-existing power of Wijemanne which affected the alleged cures, but the credulity of the minister and the others who went to him to get blessed made them imagine that they were cured.

If the Minister was really convinced about the healing power of Wijemanne, as one who was responsible for the welfare of this country, it was his duty to have per­suaded his colleague the then Minister of Health to appoint 'Uthama Sadhu' to the General Hospital, so that the country as a whole could benefit.

If 'Uthama Sadhu's claims are true, we can expect hundreds and thousands of incurable cases being brought to Ceylon from allover the world for miraculous cures. Indirectly this might even solve our problem of foreign assets!

Courtesy: Abraham Kovoor, Exposing Paranormal Claims, Published by B Pemanand, Indian CSICOP, Podannur- 641023, Date of Publication: 15-03-2000


Wednesday, 4 July 2012

My Encounters with Healing In The Name Of Jesus!

Narendra Nayak

My first public encounters as a rationalist were with evangelists - the crusading ones claiming to heal the sick, the blind and the lame. It was in 1975 or so when I was a student at Kasturba Medical College, Manipal. I used to come to Mangalore on Saturdays and Sundays. One of these weekends when I had come home and was relaxing with friends, we got the news that there was a miracle healer called Chris Panos having his sessions on one of biggest maidans of Mangalore. One of our friends who is now no more was gushing about him having restored hearing to two of his cousins and he was a medical student! So, that leant all the more credibility to the claims and some of us rushed to the place. There was a high podium there with a well dressed man in a three piece suit, holding a microphone in his hand and shouting at the top of his voice- Heal in the name of Jesus and was exhorting the audience to shout halleluiah praise the lord which they were doing at the top of their voices. One of those on the dais was a familiar figure- he was the retired chief engineer of Mangalore Harbour project and his name was Panditaradhya. He was lead to the stage holding a walking stick and was ordered in the rolling baritone of Chris Panos throw away that walking stick and walk in the name of Jesus and the stick was snatched from his hands. The poor man somehow managed to reach the sides of the stage and held on to the ropes hanging on for dear life and then came shout from the hero- look Jesus has healed him! Again there was a big shout from the audience- praise be to the lord! Then was the turn of a girl whose arm was paralysed since birth- again the voice took over- Chris Panos said bend your hand and she bent it. At this I saw the arms of the girl - both were of the same size. So, I went to the stage and asked him how come both her hands appear the same since you claim that one of them was paralysed since birth! He was flummoxed and told me that it was a miracle.

www.atheistcartoons.com
There were hundreds of people waiting to be cured some of them in very pathetic conditions and my temper was slowly rising. On the sides I saw a quadriplegic beggar who was crawling on all four limbs and a begging bowl on a wooden trolley. I bribed him with 50 paise( which was a good amount in those days) and asked him to come with me. I took him near the stage and requested the volunteers to take him on the stage and get him cured. They told me that cures do not happen on stage but only the cured are allowed there. I told them that this man was deaf also and his deafness was cured and hence he was to be taken on the stage to let all know about it! But, the volunteers could sense a trap in that and said no, I told them why not and there was a commotion. Disturbed by this the great healer came to the side of the stage and demanded to know as to what was happening. I told him that this man should be cured. He said I don’t cure. I asked him then who does? He replies Jesus. I told him in that case-ask Jesus to cure him! There was a commotion and a policeman asked me what was happening and why I was creating a disturbance. At this, the healer came to the side of the stage and kicked the railings and shouted go back. When I looked around there was no one and I was the only one left! I told the policeman that I just want to check the healing powers of this guy and he said fair enough go ahead! At this Chris Panos called me to him asked for my hand pulled me close to him and whispered go away peacefully my friend in the name of god! I said I am an atheist and god is a dirty word to me. Then he told me go my friend otherwise something may happen to you. I replied don’t worry if something happens to me twice that or probably more is going to happen to you. Just at that moment somebody threw a wire at the power cables and the lights went off. Then there was a disturbance and the healing session came to an end! I was furious and started shouting at all the helpless people who had come in search of a miraculous cure there! In the meanwhile some of the saffron gang who had come there to try and disturb his meeting asked me whether anything happened when he kept his hand on my head- I told them nothing.  Their reaction was that they had all been scared that he had some sort of a power and that is why they did not have the courage to disturb him and that they now knew that nothing happened to me despite he keeping his hand over my head, they would come next day and teach him a lesson!
     

Teaching him a lesson is something that they really did the next day! They waited until it was dark and then tripped the electricity connection by short circuiting the wires and started molesting the girls when they raised their hands shouting halleluiah which resulted in a stampede and the cancellation of the proposed one week healing program in two days! Then followed the mutual recriminations the Catholics said he had been invited by the protestants and they said the opposite! Any way the whole thing ended in a fiasco and Chris Panos had to stop his healing sessions.
      
In 1977, he came once more to Mangalore and this time we were well prepared, we had printed pamphlets asking why this man from Greece had to come to India to heal when there were enough number of patients there itself. We had also questioned as to why the police were not taking action against him for practicing medicine without a license etc. These pamphlets were distributed in such a bold manner even to those who were in the audience that many thought that it was something being handed over by the organizers themselves! We had also challenged him that we would show him patients to be cured and if he did that we were ready to admit that he had the healing powers. At that time something really surprising happened- the program was cancelled. We were summoned by the police who asked for our pamphlets. Later on we came to know that the police inspector who was in charge of the security had called this man Chris Panos shown him the pamphlet  and had told him that we had complained that he was practicing medicine without a license. He was also told that the Inspector would take him to the nearby hospital and show him a few patients to be cured. If he did that he was assured nothing would be done to him but if he did not he would be arrested for fraud! Chris Panos told the police that he was just conducting prayer meetings and he was not curing people. He was asked to give that in writing and was let off. Later on we came to know that many of the so called cures were stage managed affairs with paid people first acting as if they were handicapped and then appearing normal when summoned to the stage as an evidence of being healed. In the case of the ex chief engineer it was said that he had had a brain hemorrhage and was slowly recovering. When he was called to the stage and his walking stick pulled away he had not alternative but somehow try to reach to the side of the stage as he did not want the public embarrassment of falling down as there was nothing to hold on there!     


The next day the ads about blind seeing, deaf hearing, and the lame walking were off and instead there were announcements of prayer meetings. The show was a flop and was wound up earlier than planned. So, that was the end of our session with this man Chris Panos. A few years later another healer called Peter Youngren appeared on the scene and his ads were too of the same type. This time we were ready with our pamphlets and had repeated the same challenges. But, here there were the police in full strength and we were not allowed to go into the venue but were asked to distribute our pamphlets at a distance from it. I had the time to visit it and it was quite apparent that the whole thing was an attempt at proselytizing in the name of healing and probably a few psychosomatic cases would have got some relief.
     
But, as the protests against these so called healing sessions started, the modus operandi of these people also changed. They started calling their meetings as prayer meetings and claimed that the ill would be prayed for. The venue of the meetings was also shifted to a place called as mission compound which was an enclosed area surrounded by the houses of Christians and would be easily protected from the attacks from outsiders. The process of saffronisation had also started and the Hindu groups were gaining strength. Around the end of the 20th century as rumors started about the end of the world, there was the big ‘prayer meeting’ of Dinakaran organized at Mangalore where large crowds of Christians-both Roman Catholics and protestants were supposed to gather ad pray, There were some feelers from the Hindu outfits that we should protest against that and I realized then that they wanted to use our shoulders to fire at them and told them that if they wanted to do that they could do it on their own. A few years later there was this man from Philippines- Alex Orbito who was supposed to perform psychic surgery- operating with his bare hands and removing what was called as bad elements from the body. He used to plunge his hand into the patients abdomen and a pink liquid would ooze out- an obvious case of palming! At the time when he was in Bangalore, his first session was in the Karnataka Legislative assembly and his first ‘patients’ were the ministers of the Karnataka govt.! This got him publicity and the next day there were long lines of ‘patients’ waiting to be operated by him outside the hotel where he was ‘operating’ it was estimated that he had collected several millions of rupees in one day charging a sum of Rs.3000 for a 3 minute session of ‘operation’. I could not visit that place as I had already fixed programs at a nearby place for three days. But, he was spirited away by organizers of his program as one lawyer from Kolar had filed a case against him at the Karnataka High court and the court had ordered his arrest. He was allowed to escape as some of the top police officials were his supporters and had arranged for his going out of the country. Later on it was revealed that he had been jailed in USA for practicing medicine without a license.
          

But our campaign against his healing went on full swing and I went to Bangalore to demonstrate this ‘psychic surgery’ at a TV studio along with a panel discussion which was supposed to be attended by one of the members of the Karnataka cabinet who had subjected herself to this ‘surgery’. It was not a surprise that the lady did not turn up! Along with this we demonstrated this in a few medical colleges including the Bangalore Medical College. It was here that I came to know that a pediatric surgeon was one of the supporters of this Alex Orbito and had arranged for his program. I also met one Dr.Rao who was the Chairman of the anti quackery cell of the Karnataka State Branch of the Indian Medical Association he informed me that when he had gone to a meeting at a very prestigious venue where Alex Orbito was giving a public lecture he was ridiculed by a supposedly upright policeman called Sangliana that what he was doing protesting when his President was on the dais. That was a fact that the meeting had the state President of the Indian Medical Association on the dais! This clearly shows the hypocrisy of the medical profession. Anyway, this Dr.Rao had taken a list of the names and addresses of the ‘patients’ who had been treated by Alex Orbito and was trying to follow up on that. The ‘psychic surgery’ performed by me for the TV channel was broadcast and I got a number of invitations to demonstrate that. I was told that a number of religious maths had invited Alex Orbito to do his treatment which he could not as he had to run away! Anyway, some of the top cops of Karnataka had helped him to escape.       

Then was the Benny Hinn episode-that was a year after the tsunami had struck the shores of India. He was supposed to come to Bangalore, conduct his prayer meetings for the peace for the souls of the affected people and also conduct the healing sessions. We were the first group to protest against his coming and had challenged him to demonstrate his healing powers on patients shown by us. At that time the congress party was in power and probably to please their ‘madam’ they rolled out a red carpet welcome for this man. The protests against his visit turned violent and there was quite some damage to public property due to the protests of the saffron gangs and the Bharatiya Janatha Party which was in the opposition at the time. The meeting was at a airport which was no longer in use and was attended by millions of people and was taken as a show of strength by the Christian community! The meeting was attended by the Chief Minister and some ministers of the central govt. too! However, the tough  ex cop Sangliana who was then a member of the parliament of the Bharathiya Janata Party issued advertisements in the local press asking people to attend the meeting when the rest of his party colleagues were busy protesting against that!


   
There was supposed to be an encounter with a healer called as Jira Ma in Jamshedpur which did not take place! She was supposed to be a very famous faith healer of the area drawing thousands to her sessions. Her healing sessions would start with her going into a trance and reading the bible. Her devotees who by then would be seated would have two bottles with them one of water and the other of oil. At the appointed time they would remove the caps of these bottles and pray along with her. After that they were to put on the caps and take them home for use- the water was for internal use and the oil was for external use! There was a regional meet of FIRA at Jamshedpur and the very next day her session was at a nearby stadium. So, we wanted to attend that and check on her powers and decided to so after discussions. But, we had not been aware of a reporter of a local daily around when these were going on. The very next day the newspaper carried on its front page our photographs with a bold headline- Jira ma is going to be exposed by the top rationalists of India. The element of surprise was gone and we were advised by the locals not to go there and get attacked by her devotees and we had to drop our plans. However, within a few years her nemesis came. At one of her meetings a heart patient who was waiting to be healed by her collapsed and died on the spot. She was arrested and imprisoned. These supposed healing sessions are called Changai Sabhas in the North and we have some of these ads. Our Nagpur groups have been successful in getting the Drugs and magic remedies (objectionable advertisements) act applied to them as they claim to cure disease. But, some of the Christian groups rally behind these so called healers, treating our questioning their powers as an attack against their religion. There are some of their activities going on in places on a permanent basis like in Potta in Kerala.



This was my last encounter with these groups in December, 2011 and the result of that is also mentioned along with. Since this was an attack on healing in the name of Jesus Christ most of the local papers which would be reluctant to publish anything against such claims from the groups linked with cow’s urine, exorbitant claims of yoga and Ayurveda were keen to publicise this. This was the statement
Healing disease by Chosen Generation of Ministries!

    
For those who may be having problems with married life, parents and children. Financial, health etc. etc. including things like satanic bondage the solution is well at Hand as Jesus is coming soon!
   
I am in possession of a pamphlet by an organization called as Chosen Generation of Ministries® which states that all these problems and more can be solved by them and two cell numbers have been provided when I called them and informed that I was suffering from cancer of the prostate and was told by one Mr.John that they could heal it, I was asked to come to Suratkal( a suburb of Mangalore) on the coming Monday and their god would heal anything!
Funnily enough this issue was brought to my attention by a Roman Catholic who was angry with this group for ‘baptising’ people and giving them communion again thereby converting them to their sect. I was also told that they were seeking donations for their cause and were mesmerizing people. While we have a Minister who claims that rolling on leaves on which Brahmins have had their meals, these people have gone one step ahead and have claimed that their god can heal all diseases!
In fact this hand bill attracts the provisions of the Drugs and magical Remedies (objectionable) advertisements ct, 1954 under which claiming cures for certain diseases is a cognizable offence. The authority for taking action under this is the drugs controller of Dakshina Kannada. Because, when one claims all disease, those under the provisions of this act are also covered.
  
The address of this organization is Chosen Generation of Ministries® Church Post box no 76 Udupi -576 101 and the founder and senior pastor is one Peter Quadros. Well one can claim the freedom to profess ones religion and also practice it. But, how about the claims made herein?
       
Of course however much I was keen to get my prostate healed by their prayers it was not to be. Not only I was busy that day, but the Hindutwa brigade was far busier. There was an attack by them on the premises where these ‘healings’ were going on and the usual violence followed!
     
This is an account of our encounters with those who heal with the power of Jesus. Thouigh I have been quite keen about exposing these frauds we have to be a bit on the careful side due to the propensity of the Hindutwa brigade to use our shoulders to fire at them. Not that they are exclusively dependent on us for that, but even our little bit helps! Of course we have such with those who heal with the power of many such gods, goddesses and spirits and what have you. More about that, some other time.

Sunday, 10 June 2012

Fishy Treatment of Bathina Goud Family of Hyderabad

Manoj Thazath

One killed in stampede for fish medicine

(Hyderabad, June 9, 2012)

Amid utter chaos and confusion that marked the distribution of the famous ‘fish prasadam' in the city, one person was killed in a stampede while some others suffered injuries in Kattedan, here on Friday.

Thousands of people suffering from asthma jostled with one another at the gates of the sports complex on the city outskirts, where the ‘prasadam' was to be administered by Bathina Harinath Goud's family members. The belief is that the ‘prasadam' would cure them of the respiratory disorder. The yellow dough-like medicine, ingredients of which are kept a secret, is rolled into a small ball, put in the mouth of a live ‘murrel' fingerling and pushed down the throats of the patient.

(The Hindu, June 9, 2010)


Desperately hoping for a cure for their chronic asthma, thousands of patients and their relatives throng at this annual event where a family hailing from the twin-city of Hyderabad makes these credulous patients swallow "fish prasadam" - live murrel fingerlings dipped in what the organizers call ‘herbal medicine’.

Earlier, they used to call their offering ‘fish medicine’. In 2005, however, with the Andhra Pradesh High Court, acting on a petition filed by the rationalist group Jana Vigyan Vedike, directing the organizers of the spurious treatment not to use the word ‘medicine’, they started calling it ‘fish prasadam’. But this change in nomenclature does not seem to have the desired effect. With the open complicity of various government departments (the State Fisheries Department, for instance, “arranged for 80,000 ‘murrel' fish” for the event this year) the crowd continues to swell every passing year.

Image Courtesy:
http://srisrilara.blogspot.in/
The Baithini Goud family that administers this 'treatment' claims that some saint had handed over to their ancestors, in 1845, a secret formula of medicine as a cure for asthma.1. It is not clarified who the saint was, why the saint had selected this family to administer it, or why the ‘medical formula’ should remain a secret. Or why the medium for administering the ‘herbal medicine’ should be a fish. But the last point perhaps is understandable because the family administering this ‘secret cure’ belongs to the Goud caste, for whom eating fish is not a taboo. What is interesting however is that with the popularity of their medicine picking up, attracting patients belonging to the ‘twice-born’ castes too for whom fish is forbidden food, the treatment evolved! Now the murrel fish is no more a necessity – jaggery is equally fine, though the trade mark remains the murrel fish! Who can now say that providers of miracle cures and alternative medicines do not experiment!

Life Positive peddles nonsense 

This miracle treatment has a strange course – it has to be taken once every year for three consecutive years for the patient to be cured of the disease for ever! The medicines should not be administered on any day of the year, mind you – it should be on the ‘auspicious day’ of "Mrigishira Karthi", which is fixed each year by none other than astrologers.2 During these three years, following the ritual of swallowing live fish, the patient has to follow ‘a strict diet for 45 days’. “Once the patient has swallowed the live fish, three doses of extra medicine is provided, to be taken on three successive auspicious days - Arudra Karthi, Punarvasu Karthi and Pushyami Karthi, which fall every 15 days in a regulated span of 45 days. Apart from this, the patient has to be under strict diet control for 45 days” (LifePositive, November 1999)3

How does their fishy medicine work? Well, it is a miracle! Is not their medical formula a secret? But the Goud family is forthcoming at least on the role of the fish component of their ‘miracle medicine”:

“This live fish travels, wagging its tail and fins, through the throat and negotiates the phlegm congestion, providing a 100% cure”4 

If you start visualizing a fish moving, wagging its tail and fins as if through a stream, from your pharynx to esophagus to your stomach (the normal path of the food you eat), you are thoroughly mistaken. That’s not where this fish goes. It goes right into your lungs and ‘negotiates the phlegm congestion”!

If you think I am misleading or exaggerating, here is Life Positive, the journal that peddles every new-age nonsense, clarifying it for you in no uncertain terms:

“As the fish moves down the windpipe, it opens pores blocked by phlegm, thus making way for the herbal paste” (Life Positive, November 1999).

Fish moving down the windpipe? Are they joking? Do the author and the editor of the journal never ever coughed up tiny food particles that accidentally entered their trachea or windpipe?

Pulmonary Aspiration

Assuming that they didn’t, let us refer them to a Wikipedia article to get some idea of what the consequences of pulmonary aspiration are. [Pulmonary Aspiration is the medical terminology for, to quote Wikipedia, “the entry of material (such as pharyngeal secretions, food or drink, or stomach contents) from the oropharynx or gastrointestinal tract into the larynx (voice box) and lower respiratory tract (the portions of the respiratory system from the trachea (windpipe) to the lungs)]:

Consequences of pulmonary aspiration range from no injury at all, to chemical pneumonitisor pneumonia, to death within minutes from asphyxiation. These consequences depend in part on the volume, chemical composition, particle size, presence or absence of infectious agents, and underlying health status of the person. In healthy people, aspiration of small quantities of material is common and rarely results in disease or injury. People with significant underlying disease or injury, especially hospitalized patients, are at greater risk for developing respiratory complications following pulmonary aspiration because of certain factors such as depressed level of consciousness and impaired airway defenses (gag reflex and/or respiratory tract antimicrobial defense system).5

If this is what happens when tiny food particles accidentally get into your lungs, can you even imagine a fish ‘swimming’ through your windpipe and lungs? It is evident that the Goud family and the worthy editors of Life Positive magazine who have taken upon themselves the task of marketing medical charlatanism are ignorant of even the basic human anatomy and the causes and symptoms of asthma. It is shocking to see thousands of chronic asthma patients flocking to these quacks without worrying about the hazards involved.

Though the Goud family continues to maintain that theirs is a ‘secret formula’ handed down through generations, they were directed by the Court in 2005 to give samples for scientific analysis. The laboratory test concluded that it had no medical properties. It was following this test that the court directed the organizers not to use the word ‘medicine’

Though it is reported that this ‘treatment’ is offered free of cost (the Goud family claims that the saint who had gifted this secret medical formula had made them take oath that the treatment would be offered free of cost; the 'medical formula' would however remain secret – Oh! What a magnanimous saint!), we think that various financial aspects of this annual event should be seriously looked into, studied, and investigated – including the role of the government departments. Who bears, for instance, the cost of 80000 murrel fish supplied by the Fisheries Department of the Government of Andhra Pradesh? At what cost it is supplied? Why does the State Government continue to involve in these affairs by arranging the venue, supplying murrel fish, and making special transportation arrangements from various parts of the state for the patients to reach the venue, despite the fact that it is proven in the laboratory tests that the ‘treatment’ is medically worthless?

'Alternative Medicine' and Placebo Effect

But the more important question to be asked is why do people, even the educated, intelligent lot, fall for this medical charlatanism?

Analysing the growing popularity of Complementary and Alternative Medicine in the United States in the 1990s, R. Barker Bausell says in his book Snake Oil Science that modern medical science’s answers to ‘chronic, non-life-threatening illnesses that drastically affected their victims’ quality of life’ left a great deal to be desired. Pharmaceutical marketing created the expectation that there did exist a medical answer for every human complaint. However, consumers “dissatisfaction with conventional medicine’s inability to treat, much less fix, chronic, sometimes disabling aches and pains” has created demand, which is met by the supply of these ‘alternative treatments’.

Bausell says  “… millions of intelligent people could be correct when they conclude that their symptoms were relieved as soon as they received a complementary and alternative medical treatment, but incorrect when they conclude that the relieve was due to the treatment itself … the best scientific evidence available suggests that the genesis of this relief is something else entirely. And while this possibility may seem counterintuitive, I will suggest that this “something else” is actually the placebo effect, a phenomenon recognized at least since the time of Hippocrates and used by physicians ever since".6


Notes:

  1. http://topnews.ae/content/27817-fish-prasadam-165-years-old-belief-treat-asthma - Accessed on June 10, 2012
  2. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bathini_Goud_Brothers#Nature_of_the_treatment – Accessed on June 10, 2012
  3. http://www.lifepositive.com/body/traditional-therapies/fish-therapy/fish-therapy.asp - Accessed on June 10, 2012
  4. http://www.bathinifish.com/history.htm - Accessed on June 10, 2012
  5. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulmonary_aspiration - Accessed on June 10, 2012
  6. R. Barker Bausell, 2007, Snake Oil Science: The Truth About Complementary and Alternative Medicine, Oxford University Press, New York.

Thursday, 24 May 2012

Are Natural Foods Always Non-toxic?


Radha Gopalan


No.  There are several naturally occurring toxins in plant and animal foodstuffs.  Toxins are poisonous substances of natural origin and can be harmful to human beings.  But food poisoning, in our mind, is usually associated with microbes or environmental contaminants.  A foodstuff is not always safe just because it is natural.

Concern about the safety of food has been reported even amongst our early ancestors. Pre-historic men were primitive toxicologists – they only consumed food that was found safe for animals.  But they were always subject to food hazards arising from food plant poisons, decomposition or deficiencies in their diet. The active substances in plants can be toxic if unchanged. However, primitive man discovered that some toxins were rendered safe in the preparation process – cooking, soaking etc.

Poisonous plant chemicals are called phytotoxins.  These include alkaloids, polypeptides, amines, glycosides, oxalates, resins and toxalbumins. The natural contaminants range from toxic alkaloids in the white potato with high carbohydrate content to oxalates in spinach.  Some edible mushrooms are also poisonous.  Mycotoxins (toxicity due to fungus) on grains and absorptions of trace elements (zinc, selenium, lead, copper, cadmium, etc) are other toxic contaminants of natural origin.

Legumes and oil-bearing plants that are highly proteinacious are also highly toxic.  Red blood cells clump together when we eat improperly cooked beans and some other leguminous plants. Beans also contain a substance called tyrosine which gets metabolized in normal persons.  But in heart patients, who take medicines, the normal metabolism is hindered and eating beans can lead to a hypertensive crisis.

Ricin, a toxalbumin, is a component of castor bean that causes burning of the mouth, throat and stomach, convulsions and respiratory distress.

Lathyrism – a disease common in India – manifests as muscular weakness and paralysis of the lower limbs.  This is due to the intake of the pulse lathyrus (khesari) dal as a major portion of one’s diet.   The chemical aminopropionitile is an enzyme inhibitor which weakens blood vessel walls and bones.  Erucic acid, a natural lipid found in rapeseed oil and mustard seed oil, is potentially toxic and can cause heart disease.

Honey bees visit a number of plants to collect honey.  If they visit toxin containing flowers, the toxicity can reach us through the honey indirectly.  There has been one such report of honey poisoning in Asia Minor.

Intolerance to lactose or milk sugar is common amongst adults in Asia and West Africa.  Lactose causes diarrhea and gastric problems.  This sugar is a naturally occurring component of milk.  In tolerant persons, lactose is broken down to glucose or fructose which is easily absorbed but n intolerant individuals lactose remains in the gut, ferments because of the bacteria in the gut and causes gastric disorders.

Rhubarb, tea, cocoa, spinach and beet leaves contain salts of oxalic acid in large quantities (0.02 to 1.3 per cent).  It is also present in vegetables like lettuce, turnips, carrots, peas and beans and in certain berries.  These salts are mostly found in leaves but in the rhubarb they occur in the stalks and in beets and carrots, in the roots.  Oxalic acid formed by the breakdown of the salts in corrosive on the mouth and gastrointestinal tract.  It can even cause haemorrhage.

Solanine is the glycoalkaloid present in white potato (Solanum tuberosum), brinjal and tomato, and causes gastrointestinal and neurological disorders.  The potato has a very high proportion of solanine and eating a fir amount of raw potatoes can lead to death.

Linamarin and amygdalin present in Lima beans, peaches and apricot produce hydrogen cyanide enzymatically.  This chemical is highly poisonous.  Dhurrin, a substance present in sorghum, denatures the proteins.  The consumption of huge quantities of peach and apricot kernels also leads to poisoning.  Cassava roots or manioc (tapioca) (Mamihot utilissima), the basic food in many African countries, yield 15-400 mg of cyanide per kilogram of fresh food.  The enzyme causing the release of cyanide, also contained in tapioca, is inactivated by cooking.  Low levels of cyanide residue are observed in the cassava consumed.


Gluecoisinolates present in cabbage, oilseed crops, rapeseed and mustard seed are harmful when consumed in large amounts.  They are a source of nitriles.  Eating fresh raw vegetables like cabbage, cauliflower, turnips, etc increases one’s intake of goitrogens – goiter causing compounds.  Soyabeans, groundnuts and walnuts are found to be goitrogenic in babies.  These compounds lead to considerable loss of thyroxine and thus cause goitre.

Ergotis is the effect of carcinogenic mycotoxins from the fungus ergot (Clavicepts purpurea).  It contaminates flour obtained from grains affected by the fungus and the toxin even goes up to the bread stage.  The by-products of this fungus have resulted in hallucinations and gangrene formation – ergotism.  In fact ergotism affected persons were burnt as witches in medieval times in Europe.  Other outbreaks of diseases due to mouldy foods are also well known.

Aflatoxin is a mycotoxin from fungus Aspergillus flavus and A parasciticus.  It is carcinogenic to animals, causing injury to the liver.  Ot of 400 cases of aflatoxin poisioning in India recently, 100 succumbed to hepatic diseases.  Maize, a major dietary constituent, was contaminated with aflatoxins.  Also groundnuts grown in humid areas can cause aflatoxin poisoning because the fungus infects the plants more easily in such climates.

Drinking herbal teas and medicines have reported to be the cause of liver injury in Jamica, Indian and Afghanistan.  Pyrrolizidine alkaloids were found in teas that resulted in hepatic disease.  Another typical example that is carcinogenic is chewing betel leaves with arecanut or tobacco.  Forty per cent of mouth and throat cancer prevalent in India is because of the toxicity caused by the alkaloids arecoline and nicotine present in tobacco, betel and arecanut.

Some mushrooms can be poisonous when eater, some are deadly.  Gautama Buddha is said to have died of mushroom poisoning.  Some mushrooms, though poisonous when fresh, are edible when cooked, dried and salted.  Muscarine and amanitine are among the toxic substances present in various mushrooms that affect man.

Zootoxins are animal food toxins. Blue fin tuna, mackerel and swordfish, when left at room temperature for long hours, produce a chemical called saurine.  This is a histamine releasing substance causing vomiting, nausea, itching, etc.  Jellyfish have protenacious toxins that get inactivated on heating and by gastric juices.  Biotoxication is mostly caused by fish.  The toxins are present in fresh fish and are not destroyed by heat or gastric juices.  Several species of sharks can cause severe intoxication.  The bones of mackerel contain an oil which is purgative by nature.  Another kind of fish, commonly known as gobi fish, causes poisoning because of the presence of a very toxic substance called terodotoxin.  Liver poisoning by sharks, tuna and sea bass is due to the presence of high levels of vitamin A concentration in the liver of these fish.  Some turtle meat becomes extremely poisonous causing nausea, vertigo, cramps, etc.  Its pharmacological and chemical properties are unknown.

The sea-anemone has a toxic polysaccharide that is inactivated by heat.  A popular oriental food, sea cucumber, is a source of gastro-intestinal disorders which are due to saponins – a group of glycosides made up of sugars.  These are also present in a wide variety of plants.  The burning and itching sensations caused by eating shell fish are due to the presence of pyrophenophorbide, a toxic substance that is absorbed through the skin.

With the growing knowledge of natural toxicants present in plants, and animals, our doubts about so-called “safe” foods also increase.  But they need not.  The question is not whether toxic substances are present in some foods or not; the answer is always “yes” to begin with.  But, as Paracelsus, a Swiss alchemist and physician, puts it, “All things are poison for there is nothing without poisonous qualities.  It is only the dose which makes a thing a poison”.

(This essay was first published in July 1987 issue of Science Age (now defunct). Ms Radha Gopalan has an M.Phil in mycology from Southampton University, UK)

Sunday, 12 June 2011

Baba Ramdev: Yogi or Commissar?


Ram Puniyani
 
Ramdev has been probably the most successful of God men of recent times. He claims to have a following of over a billion people. There are an infinite number of people claiming that his yoga therapy and medicines work wonders for their health. Baba in a short span of time has built a multi million empire, his Trust is owning series of Ashrams, ayurvedic drug factories, yoga training centers and many such things, in India and abroad. Overall the medicines prescribed-marketed by him are selling like hot cakes. He himself adorns the divine status and his followers also regard him so, a saint, above the worldly matters. His saffron robes are a symbol of renunciation as such. All this is remarkable, good of both the Worlds, as he is not only wearing divine halo but is also presiding over the empire running into hundreds of crores of rupees built in last decade or so and now entering politics too.

In our country where currently rational thought and scientific thinking has been pushed to the back foot, the claims that his methods are scientific go unchallenged by and large. As per him he can cure Cancer, AIDS and what have you. He also states that homosexuality is a disease, something for which he has a yogic cure. Earlier he had a spat with Brinda Karat, on the issue of contents of the medicines, powder of animal bones in the samples from his factories and on the issue of wages for the workers. Baba claiming to base his Yoga on scientific ground angrily dismissed the issues raised by Brinda Karat, and one does not know what happened to the wage issue of the workers of his factory.

There are not many who can dare to raise legitimate question in the public domain about what is science? What is the method of science and whether mere reading and following of scriptures can be called as scientific? The issues related to the role of double blind trials, biochemical analysis, pharmaceutical composition and their side effects cannot be raised, as in doing so one can be easily labeled as anti Hindu-Anti religious deviant. The garb of Holy clothes is the best defense against all the legitimate questions. So what is projected to be working successfully can also be asserted to be a scientific practice. One would expect that the tall claims like curing cancer and AIDS, need to be questioned as many may get misled and loose the precious time which a medical intervention can play in a positive way.

One concedes that there must be some benefits due to things practiced by Baba and the likes of him, but these need to be regulated and peer reviewed to avoid their misuse in the society at large. Science is not a monopoly of anybody and peer review and evaluation is the best regulator for decisions about medications-practices for society. This is indispensable to avoid the harm, in short term or long term sense. Divinity should not be permitted to protect the real social issues involved.

Lately Baba has been in the news not for divine or yogic reasons, but for the profane issues related to corruption, and his forming a political party which will fight the elections. While the crusade against corruption is welcome as such, one observes that his sayings about corruption are restricted to one political party. This is a partisan view, an attempt to hide the corrupt practices of other political parties and other actors involved in the issue of corruption. He is scathing against Congress on the issue of corruption and is silent about BJP’s corruption. He is vocal about something and quiet about the corruption of rich who are equal partners in this social evil. This may indicate that the saffron clothes are being used for the goals of helping the communal party and the rich.

As such corruption has more to do with unbridled power, absence of transparency and lack of social audit on the economic transactions and policies. To link it with few political actors is an attempt to hide those who give the bribes to get their work done. A principled stand will also be to ensure that all the donations coming to the Ahsrams of Baba and his types belong to the category of what is ‘accounted money’! Hope Baba has already taken care of this point before starting his campaign against corruption.

Generally the ‘divine’ people have to be standing for peace and harmony. One recalls that in the wake of 26/11 Mumbai terror attack, Baba had exhorted Indian Government to attack Pakistan, and that he will fund the war against Pakistan. One shudders to think of war mongers and that too with those having divine claims leading our political affairs. The current times have been the one where the politics has been wearing the clothes of religious identity. Baba is going one step ahead. He is trying to ride on two horses, the one of spirituality-religion and the other of entrepreneur-politician, at the same time. His association with those who have done politics by abusing religious identity, the communalists, is very clear. That may be the reason as to why he is creating hysteria around corruption by one political party rather than against corruption as a phenomenon related to our socio-political structure.

Saturday, 4 June 2011

Ramdev - The Nuttiest Guru!

Ramdev is the nuttiest of yoga gurus we have seen in recent years. Here is a sample of his wisdom retrieved from a recent interview he gave to Tehelka:

On Cleansing Corruption
 

If the black money from abroad comes back into the same corrupt system, how will it reach the people?

That’s why the system also needs to be changed. For that the biggest solution is to get up and do yoga in the morning. And meditate. If a person works every day on his body and mind, that person’s body and mind will be so pure that he will not want to cause harm to another being. Improving the spiritual quotient of society is the best way to reform it.

On Homosexuality

You’ve also been controversial for your opinions on homosexuality.

I consider homosexuality unnatural and a mental disorder. A bad habit. Many people acquire bad habits and get addicted to them. I’ve read all the scientific research on this subject and I’m speaking to you after having read that.


(Interview with TEHELKA, Vol 8, Issue 22, Dated 04 June 2011: 

***

Leave alone achieving purity of body and mind or at least his’ medicines’ working as placebo, this quack’s concoctions are found to be positively harmful to many. See this report in Mumbai Mirror (16 May 2011):


Baba Ramdev’s cure for hair loss blocks woman’s food pipe

Lata Mishra


In an attempt to get out of the frying pan, she jumped right into the fire. A 39-year-old Bhayandar resident, who consumed ayurvedic powder to prevent loss of hair promoted by and sold at Baba Ramdev's yoga institute had to undergo surgery lasting three hours to clear out the block from her food pipe to the abdomen. Normally, such surgeries take about 15 minutes.    

Jashmi Shankar Narapula, who could neither swallow nor speak, underwent surgery at KEM Hospital, Parel on Friday.

A medico-legal case has been registered at the Bhoiwada Police Station, while the powder, prescribed by yoga guru Baba Ramdev's Patanajli Yogpeeth, has been sent for analysis.

The institute has refuted the allegation, saying that they had received no other complaints of the kind.

Narapula said that she had been losing hair for the last few years and was tempted to try the quick fix after seeing an advert of the yog patanajali medicine on Baba Ramdev's show on television.

Narapula purchased the powder from the Yog Patanjali shop located in Shanti Nagar in Bhayandar on Wednesday. “An ayurveda consultant at the store prescribed two types of powders which I was advised to take in the morning on an empty stomach,” she said. “I took the powder once a day for two days. Suddenly, I realised I could not speak or swallow. When I tried to speak, I experienced a sharp pain.”

That’s when her husband took her to a general physician. “The doctor said she would have to undergo an endoscopy surgery for which she would have to be hospitalised,” said her husband Shankar.

At the hospital, an x-ray showed a foreign body lodged in her food pipe. “We advised her to eat bananas for an entire day, as we generally advise patients with a blocked food pipe,” said head of KEM Hospital’s Ear Nose Throat Department, Dr Neelam Sathe, terming it a rare case. “I was surprised she could not eat anything, not even sip liquids.”
    
“We decided to put her through endoscopic surgery. Her food pipe was clogged with some black, sticky material. Being hard, we were unable to pull it out using forceps.

We tried to suction it (using vacuum pressure) but it did not help,” said Dr Sathe. “A vigorous saline flush with a repeat suction helped pull out the material.”

Dr Sathe said that the patient had, in her medical history, said that she had consumed powder given by “Baba Ramdev’s ayurvedic store”. “It appears that the powder had not dissolved 24 hours after she swallowed it.

This is very strange and we have alerted the police. The material pulled out from her food pipe has been sent for analysis. Narapula’s food pipe has been damaged but she is out of danger now. A little delay could have proved fatal,” said Dr Sathe.

‘Products tested in lab’

Owner of Yog Patanjali store where Narapula bought the powder, Punnalal Gupta, said, “I have been running Baba’s Yog Patanjali shop since a month and half, but nobody has come with any such complaint.  “For hair loss, we usually recommend oil, not powder.”

Yog Patanjali’s Mumbai spokesperson, Sudhir Naik, said, It is the first complaint we have received in the last five years since we set up our stores in Mumbai. Our product has already been tested in laboratories at our main centre in Hyderabad. We will conduct a proper inquiry of this particular sample.”    




Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More