Showing posts with label Prabhakar Nanawaty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Prabhakar Nanawaty. Show all posts

Friday, 20 September 2013

All India Anti-Superstition Bill: Letter from Prabhakar Nanawaty

We reproduce an email received from Mr. Prabhakar Nanawathy, Editor of "Thought & Action", the organ of Andhashradda Nirmoolan Samiti (ANiS, founded by Dr Narendra Dabholkar), which was instrumental in getting the anti-superstition bill passed by the Maharashtra Assembly.

The Samiti is now planning to have a similar bill passed by our Parliament.

You may contact Mr. Prabhakar Nanawathy through his Email ID: pkn.ans@gmail.com


Dear friends,

We at ANS, are contemplating Anti - Superstition Bill at all India level.

In this respect we need your help on following:

Typical superstitions prevailing in our country – since we are talking of an all India legislation, we should try and give examples from different parts and not just Maharashtra .

Particular superstitions related to women – aangaat yene, denial of worship, witch hunting, exclusion of widows, practices related to pregnancy, reproductive cycle, etc. with the materialist explanation for each phenomenon in brief to point out the irrationality in them.

You may name these superstitions in local language and give a few details in just a sentence or two. For example, In Maharashtra we have superstitions like Karani, Jaran - Maran, Bhanamati, Vashikaran etc. Similarly other states may have such practices.

We need just a few names.

I hope you will do the needful. (This is bit urgent. Quick reply will help us immensely.)

Regards,

PKN

Friday, 8 February 2013

Disenchanting India: An Overview of Rationalism in India

Prabhakar Nanawaty

India is not only a land of religion, superstition and blind beliefs, but also atheism, rationalism, humanism, skepticism and agnostics. It is a land of enlightenment, philosophical quest for truth and practical application of (rationalistic) principles for common good…..
Dr. G. Vijayam

While reading above quotation, one will wonder whether it is really true, since we all the while see only the degradation of humanism and glorification of irrationalism all around us. However Johannes Quack, who is academically qualified in Religious Studies, Philosophy and Anthropology and is currently a research fellow at McGill University, Montréal, had painstakingly documented various aspects of rationalism as practiced in India by traveling the length and breadth in India. During his travel he met many contemporary rationalists and recorded their views about rationalism. In fact he was in search of an organization which has practical approach towards rationalism. By chance he attended a seminar of Federation of Rationalist Associations in India hosted by Maharashtra Andhashraddha Nirmoolan Samiti, ANS (the author however, addresses ANS as ANiS throughout the book) and chose ANS as his field work for his research thesis. While interviewing the rationalists in various part of India and describing their views on rationalism in general, he spent more time with ANS activists to record their views in particular. The book, Disenchanting India: Organized Rationalism and Criticism of Religion in India, is the result of his studies, observations and experiences. During the ethnographic fieldwork on the aims and activities of ANS, he accompanied teams at actual sites, and observed critically the activities like miracle bursting, poster exhibitions, lectures and debates, street plays etc during public performances conducted in the villages, schools and colleges.

This book is not like any other promotional material with gorgeous titles like Incredible India, Emerging India, Fascinating India Shining India etc. The essential content of this book is about the Indian rationalist, atheist, humanist, and freethinkers' movement. The prevailing rationalist movements in India are explicitly intent to challenge belief in supernatural powers of irrational efficacy as practiced by charismatic gurus even in this age of advanced science and technology. All these rationalist movements have aimed to show a way out of their enchanted – imaginative world towards a rational and this worldly way of life in spite of most of them are preoccupied with religion, spirituality, magic and miracles. In this connection the rationalists stress upon that there has always been rationalism and criticism of religion through out the historical period of India. The main advocates were Charvakas, Lokayatas, Basaveshwar, Sant Kabir, Sant Tukaram, Raja Ram Mohan Roy, Mahatma Phule, Pandita Ramabai, Agarkar, Maharshi Karve,  Raghunath Karve, Periyar E.V. Ramasami, M.N. Roy, Gora, Dr. Ambedkar , Abraham Kovoor etc.

In fact the content of this book is a published doctoral thesis of the author's research work. The author calls his research as 'multisited' ethnography. In classical research, researchers generally limit their efforts to interviews, attending seminars, studying related documents, collecting the inputs by circulating the questionnaire, visiting the places and videotaping etc. But this researcher in addition to these methodologies of research gets involved with the organization by critically studying and spending as much time as possible with the activists to get feel and insight of the organization under study. He critically assesses the aims and goals, actions and thinking, structure and set up, profile and agenda, interpretation of rationalism and ideas about way of life by field activists and intellectuals of the organization to corroborate his findings. His critical assessment of ANS can be summed up as a 'Social Audit'.

The first part of this book is about the Indian Rationalists of the past era which has been based upon sparse literature available on this topic. The author tries to explain the notion of 'mode of disbelief' and its relationship to the notion of 'mode of religiosity'. In this regard, author elaborates the concepts of 'rationality', 'irrationalism' and 'rationalization' as employed by various Western philosophers and compares these concepts in Indian context. For some, rationalism means to fight for justice and equality, to avoid violence and to try to find the truth. For a few, rationalism is that philosophy of life which is based upon the reasoning faculty of a person. That may be the one of the reasons why Indian rationalists call themselves as buddhivaadi, vivekvaadi, tarkikvaadi, yuktivaadi, etc even manavataavaadi too. This difference appears to be related to the stand that has been taken by the individual in terms of religion, existence/non-existence of God, etc. For example, humanists are simply atheists who believe in living purposeful and moral lives.  As such rationalists want to link humanism, rationalism, atheism, science and technology, the scientific temper and power of reason in order to live a contented life, emotionally and physically. While concluding theoretical aspects of rationalism, author quotes Max Weber and Charles Taylor extensively.

In the next part, he traces the roots of organized rationalism in India by quoting Charvaka and Vedic materialism. He also describes Bhakti movement spread by saints like Basaveshwar, Kabir, Tukaram etc who questioned the blind traditions practiced during that period. In fact these saints attacked the superstitions prevailing in the society. However, rationalism in strictest sense only appeared during colonial period where western philosophers like Ingersoll, Bradlaugh, and Bertrand Russell etc started dominating the minds of the intellectuals who studied English language and were exposed to western culture. Agarkar, Mahatma Phule, Periyar E. V. Ramasamy etc were the founders of the organized rationalism in India in later half of 19th century. In fact, these movements can be termed as religious reform movements to contextualize the emergence of rationalism.

Early 20th century saw growth of various Rationalist organizations which were set up in places like Delhi, Hyderabad, Nagpur, Bombay, Vijaywada, Bhilai, Rourkela, Madras, Coimbatore, Kanyakumari, Madurai, Amrutsar etc. by well educated Indian intellectuals with strong affinities to Western education and culture. Jawaharlal Nehru, M.N. Roy etc contributed for the growth of rationalism in India. Atheist Centre, founded in 1940 by Gora appears to be the milestone in practical rationalism. R.D. Karve and his colleagues wrote extensively on various aspects of rationalism in their 'Reason' magazine in spite of opposition from the society and rulers. These organizations started challenging Gurus and 'Godmen'  like Sathya Saibaba. Dr. H. Narasimhaiah and Abraham Kovoor tried their best to convince the society the fraudulent activities of Saibaba and were exposing his supernatural powers. However most of the rationalists confined their activities by writing the articles in the newspapers and magazine and participating in the public debates. Abraham Kovoor gave momentum to the existing organizations by his miracle-exposure campaigns. Kovoor was quite famous for his rhetoric and was able to entertain and fascinate large groups of people by giving lecture-cum- demonstrations and exposing the tricks of the 'Godmen'. Shri B. Premanand of Kerala took over the task of exposure of Godmen and he toured extensively to spread the message. There was tremendous response to his lectures from the public and he inspired many youths of post independent India.

The remaining portion of the book covers various aspects of ANS which was chosen as field work for author's research. Author had given ethnographical account of ANS in detail. He had described in detail the ANS activities like spreading scientific temper, campaign against superstitions, exposure of Godmen, efforts to enact the anti-superstition bill, magazines and literature published by ANS, etc. While accompanying the group of ANS activists for a tour around Maharashtra, author was very curious about ANS and wanted to see it for himself. He wanted to know how do people react when ANS activists enter remote villages; how does ANS attempt to convince the people that some of the beliefs and events so central to their everyday lives are harmful, pathological, based on illusions or made up by people who fool and exploit them in the name of religion, traditions or rituals; do people oppose the statements, or do they ignore them or   are they converted. He observes that ANS activists always try to relate to the perspectives of villagers, children and college students and try to involve them in their programs through games, tricks, songs and other interactive elements. The programs chosen are very simple in nature and lively to participate. He concludes that the didactical methods applied are of a rather higher level.

Author observes that activists never shied away from challenging and provoking the gods, deities and spirits, ridiculing the people capable of controlling black magic and deliberately doing the most inauspicious things. In fact the programs which are of interactive in nature coerce the listeners to participate and change the attitude. Through theses participations, activists try to invoke the spirit of inquiry within them. Author had gone in detail to bring out the strengths and weaknesses of ANS which appears to be quite truthful and unbiased.  Author raises a question whether or not rationalism is to be understood as directly opposing religion, since ANS has taken a moderate and rather unspecific position in this regard. ANS related harmful religious practices with that of superstitions and advocates scientific temper as the remedy for these age-old ills.

While probing for individual interpretations and applications of rationalism in day-to-day life, author approached many activists to extract the information. He tried to find how the rationalistic attitude is applicable in family relations, marriages, festivals, births, and deaths etc. Surprisingly he found varied opinions in these matters. In fact, ANS activists believe that the fight against irrationality and the fight against injustice are one and the same. However author has praised non-religious marriage ceremonies and non religious ways of dealing with death as advocated by ANS.

In the concluding remarks, author is of the opinion that Indian rationalisms are in the process of trying to disenchant Indian public – that everything in the world is, in principle, explicable (by science) without any reference to supernatural entities (like religion, spirituality and miracles). He takes an overview of the world rationalistic movements and tries analysis of them in Indian context. In fact rationalism has come very long way in various descriptions like Agnostics, Atheists, Brights, Clandestine, Freethinkers, (Secular) Humanists, Infidels, Secularists, liberals, etc.  He concludes that Indian Rationalist Movement can be seen as a part of a longer transnational movement.

As mentioned in the blurb of the book by Prof. Frederick Smith of University Iowa,
Johannes Quack has ventured into new territory in his close study of the Indian Rationalist Movement particularly its manifestations in early twenty-first century Maharashtra. He has combined ethnographic analysis, social theory, and a deep knowledge of Indian history with reflections on secularism, religious belief, rationality enhancement, and disenchantment, the result is a vivid depiction of India in the throes of modernity, in which class, gender, nationalism, and ideological and discursive strategy are contesting for the very future of India. This excellent volume must be examined by anyone interested in modern and contemporary India because it addresses in a most illuminating way a desperately understudied topic.

Disenchanting India:Organized Rationalism and Criticism of Religion in India
Johannes Quack
Oxford University Press, 2012,  pp 362



Prabhakar Nanawaty is the editor of Thought and Action, a journal published by Maharashtra Andhashraddha Nirmoolan Samiti (ANS)

Wednesday, 6 July 2011

Gopal Ganesh Agarkar: Rationalist, Secularist and Social Reformer


Book Review

Gopal Ganesh Agarkar: The Secular Rationalist Reformer
Dr. Arvind Ganachari
Popular Prakashan, Pune (2005)
Price: Rs 395, pp 371

Prabhakar Nanawaty (pkn.ans@gmail.com)

Gopal Ganesh Agarkar’s (1856-95) ideas mark the apex of the secular rationalist trend during renaissance of nineteenth century Maharashtra. Arvind Ganashari’s book, Gopal Ganesh Agarkar, The Secular Rationalist Reformer, clearly highlights the achievements of a remarkable personality who deeply influenced the national intellectual current.

 
In one of the essays on Agarkar, Dr Ganachari describes Agarkar's contribution to rationalist thought in following words:

"In the complex movement of renaissance thought in Western India since 1818, Gopal Ganesh Agarkar’s ideas marked the apex of the rationalist strand. Agarkar was a serious student of European Enlightenment and was deeply influenced by the Utilitarian and skeptical writings of 18th and 19th century Western thinkers, especially John Stuart Mill, Herbert Spencer, August Comte, Thomas Huxley, John Morley and Edward Gibbon. Indeed, he was not ignorant of Indian classical lore. But it was the Western liberal—rational thought and the secular— scientific world-view that it represented which made intense appeal to his resilient mind. What he recognised was the revolutionary character of the rational principles, which are timeless and universal, as evolved by the Western rationalists."

In this book the author makes an in-depth study of Agarkar’s rationalist ideas in social, political, economic and other related fields that are accurately reflected in his numerous writings, first as the editor of Kesari (1881-87) and later as the founder – editor of Sudharak (1887-95). The author examines how Agarkar wanted reason and an enlightened conscience to be the sole determinant in regulating human conduct and social behaviour. His rational approach constantly re-examined all social ideas and institutions – whether they served the purpose of social utility and comfort or not. He was among the few contemporaries in whose thought and practice there was no dichotomy. "Education, not just formal but also Lokshikshan," Agarkar said, "holds key to advancement in life. He not only preached but followed: “Persuade, argue, cherish virtuous examples; bring up the youth in the habit of right opinion and right motive, shape your social arrangements so as to stimulate the best part of character”.

In his forward, the great scholar, Dr. Y.D. Phadke sums up about Agarkar in the following manner:

It is becoming increasingly difficult for individuals who have the courage of conviction to criticize politicians in power and demolish myths which influence the general public. In such an atmosphere it becomes necessary to revive the memory of Agarkar, a solitary rationalist, who fearlessly expressed his dissenting opinions and helped his contemporaries to learn by discussions and arguments. 

As a rationalist, secularist, and humanist – you may call anything – this book is a must to know more about these concepts as well as how a person faced the problems in day-to-day life when he tries to adhere to his principles and convictions. The author has put the efforts to make the book to be understood by any lay man and aptly describes the details of the events occurred during Agarkar’s life.  The book has been arranged in a very nice manner wherein the first chapter is devoted to what is rationalism, what is reason, what was the situation in the late nineteenth century in Maharashtra. The second chapter is about the life sketch of Agarkar. The third chapter includes details about how Agarkar became rationalist, who influenced him, what books he used to read etc. Agarkar’s literary works are described in the next chapter. Agarkar wrote mainly in Marathi. विकारविलसित  is a play in Marathi, the translated version of original Shakespeare’s play on Hamlet.  डोंग्रीच्या तुरुंगातील आमचे एकशे एक दिवस (Our 101 days in Dongri Prison) is a sort of prison diary of Agarkar who spent 101 days in jail along with Lokmanya Tilak who were sentenced for writing the editorial in Kesari daily and had to face  a defamation case. The editorials written by Agarkar in Keasri have been compiled and published in two volumes. Agarkar also wrote scholarly books on Marathi grammar analyzing the structure of sentences. विविध विषय संग्रह  is collection of Agarkar’s miscellaneous writings. He also translated a book from Gujarati to Marathi शेठ माधवदास रघुनाथदास यांचे आत्मलिखित पुनर्विवाह.

According to the author, Agarkar’s ideas in social, political, economic and the other related fields are accurately reflected in his numerous writings — first as the editor of Kesari (1881-1887) and later as the founder-editor of Sudharak (1887-1895). Himself an agnostic, he never denied the role that religion played in the certain stage of human development. However, he felt certain that with the growth of science and scientific knowledge, ethics will be separated from religion. He firmly believed in the persuasive power of reason in inducing people to think and overcome blind superstitious faith and to lead a wholesome life on the basis of rationality and equality. He wanted reason and enlightened conscience to the sole determinant in regulating human conduct and social behaviour. To him, no traditional idea, institution or custom was sacrosanct, and anything that was inimical to human progress had to be cast aside.
 The most important chapter in the book appears to be Critique of Hindu Society and Conception of Social Change which includes his ideas of social change, the method of reform and social issues. In fact during his brief life he had to confront issues like the age of consent controversy, on liberation of women, caste system, Sharada Sadan controversy, the panchhouda tea episode, Hindu -  Muslim riots of 1893-94. The author had taken lots of pains to bring out Agarkar’s views by going through the published as well as unpublished papers available. He describes in detail the nature of the issues, the controversies, the people involved, their ulterior motives and how Agarkar tackled these issues. It appears that most of the time Agarkar was victimized by his one time friend, Lokmanya Tilak, who took advantage of sensitive nature of Agarkar.

The next chapter is devoted on religion and morality. The author has summed up Agarkar’s views on liberalism, politics and economics in the next few chapters. He concludes the book by the article ‘Saint of Rationalism’. In one of the papers written by the author, he had emphasized how Agarkar differed with other contemporary social reformers on the question of ideology, and the method and manner in which the desired reform was to be attained. In his opinion, the word Sudharana was not just synonymous to ‘social reform’ but represented an all round human “progress”. He disagreed with other methods of social change, namely, The Mandlik School of Reform—’Reform from within’; the Telang School of Reform—’the line of least resistance’; the Method of Tradition—both Derivative (vyutpattikar) as well as Prarthana Samajists; breaking the continuity and forming a new sect; reform through social legislation; and the Method of Revolution. He preferred the Secular Rationalist Method of social change over other methods which he considered as gaun [The paper also attempts to spell-out what Agarkar meant by the Secular Rationalist Method. Agarkar firmly believed that social good presupposes a living, changing society; if the society does not keep itself in tune with the modern ideas based on rationality and equality, inevitably the forces of change would sweep away everything and bring about a revolutionary change similar to the French Revolution.

While reading the book, one will always feel that Agarkar or persons like him should have been there in the present time to speak and act fearlessly against irrational behaviour of so called intellectuals, social reformers, politicians and educated elite. Thanks to the author as well publisher to bring out such a thought provoking book!

Tuesday, 14 June 2011

Fraudulent Use of Obsolete Vaastushastra

Book Review:



Searching For The Sun In Candle Light….
(Wisdom of Vaastushastra)
Arvind Pralhad Pakhale

(Translated by Ms Suman Oak)

Prabhakar Nanawaty (pkn.ans@gmail.com)


As highlighted in the Forward written by Prof. R. V. Kolhatkar, Ex Director of Institute of Architecture and Design, Hyderabad, if one goes to any bookstall on airport, railway station or even remotely located town bus stand, there will be number attractively printed and colored books praising Vaastushastra displayed prominently in the showcase. And of course, there are customers who are ready to pay the fancy prices to buy them. But you may not find a single book challenging and exposing the myths built around Vaastushastra. Perhaps this so called Shastra is built upon    endless untruths and it may be very difficult to expose all the untruths. However Searching For The Sun In Candle Light… written by Arvind Pakhle is one book which attempts to expose the frauds and falsehoods of the Vaastushastra. In fact this book is a 'collage' of extracts from many articles, books, conversations and discourses. Since the author is a practicing builder and developer of real estate in and around Pune, he has collected wisdom of truths about Vaastushastra during his professional career and has brought out them in the book form to help the frightening and gullible common people.  



It is quite surprising that no one had heard this ancient wisdom on architecture till 1980's and it suddenly appeared on the stage and caught fancy of middle class and rich class as though it is one time remedy for all the problems associated with fast moving life in recent years. One cannot forget that the progress of the society was not at all hampered in those 2000 years earlier to recent fad of Vaastushastra. In fact one can boldly say that it appears that when Vaastushastra was not practiced then only the society made lot of progress and brought happiness and worldly comforts to the individual and society.

The author has tried to trace the historical background of Vaastushastra. According to him the cities of Harappa and Mohenjodaro evolved around 2300 BC were well planned. However, all this huge evidence of progress made in housing and town planning by the old culture was devoid of any mention of Vaastushastra. The Aryan tribes, arriving from the cold grass lands of central Asia entering into Sindhu valley in the northwest India, enslaved the native people and stabilized their own colonies. They needed to establish their superiority over the civilized natives. In this endeavor they invented abstract and mystifying concepts like heaven, hell, Moksha, Mantrashakti, and of course Chaturvarnya – caste system. They believed in Yadnya Vedi which appears to be the root of Vaastushastra. Their philosophy was founded on symbolism. Their Vedic culture gave birth to concepts like Shilpshastra, Manasar and Mayamat. Amongst them Shilpshastra narrates the basic principles of Vedic philosophy and might had more influence than other two concepts. The rules mentioned in Shilpshastra might have been propagated orally till recently. The author had listed a few details from Shilpshastra as samples. After going through these details one can conclude that the whole pseudoscience is constructed with the aim of strengthening the system of male dominance and the dominance of the society by the Chaturvarnya giving control to the Brahmins and subjugating the Shudras. The method of developing this so called 'Shastra' is quite strange which includes imaginary stories, imaginary characters like Vaastupurush, the concepts like Vaastumandal   and Brahmasthan etc. In fact the author had devoted a full chapter on this Brahmasthan and proves beyond doubt how it is impractical and illogical. Everything appears to be fantasy in this so called ancient art of building constructions. In the chapter on Prudence in Vaastushastra, the author tries to see the whole scene through the eyes of Vaastu experts and feels that this cannot be science at all.

While commenting on present situation, the author feels that the contemporary Vaastushastra as practiced by the experts selectively uses the dictates of ancient wisdom which are advantageous to them. It has taken features regarding the eight directions, plays with the meanings of Sanskritised names of these directions and how the portion of the house in particular direction is to be utilized.  No one can give logical explanations for why people staying in a building, water storage, toilet, veranda etc located in East will face the problems like sterility, death, eye disease, heart problem, paralysis etc; why stair case built in northeast should result in abortion, mental illness or sudden death. According to Vaastu authority northeast is God's direction; as such water tank should be in northeast, slope of the ground and street should be in the northeast. No one can give any logical explanation for these absurd and totally irrelevant recommendations for house constructions to be built in 21st century or houses built in the last century. In fact the author convincingly explains citing examples of two representative layouts of the flats built as per Vaastushastra norms and concludes that it is impossible to build such a house/flat adhering to Vaastushastra criteria. He questions that does it mean that all those who live in the apartments not built as per Vaastushastra are leading a wretched life? Surprisingly these connoisseurs have instant answer for such objections too. As per their argument, every apartment has some features that are approved by this science and as such they are happy. If there is no happiness, then these so called specialists will come forward and bring happiness by restructuring (demolishing!) the whole house (and charging hefty fees!). Whatever may happen they never hesitate to blow their trumpet.

The author even takes issues like shapes of the plots, the slope of the ground, examining the soil, the compound wall, the compound gate, parking arrangements etc in threadbare details in which Vaastushastra experts usually have something to comment and concludes how bizarre it seems to follow the instructions of this so called science. In fact the author wonders why the science of erecting the buildings had been linked to philosophy, religion and cosmic energy and why this science interlinks with 9 planets (Navagrahas!), 12 zodiac signs and 27 Nakshatras. However not a single book explains in what way the shape of the plot is related to its being auspicious or inauspicious. It is generally explained in terms of positive and negative energy. The whole trend of thought is simply incomprehensible. In fact shapes of the plots, directions of the roads, slopes of the grounds and even naming the eight directions are all handy work of the people. There is no point in attaching any importance to these aspects as long as they are convenient and masking them as lucky or unlucky. When science of construction was in infant stage there were some empirical tests prescribed to examine the soil on which the house is to be built or slope, shape etc so as to minimize the construction cost as far as possible. But nowadays the construction technology had advanced so much so that it can overcome any issues relating foundation and one can construct building any where or on any soil condition irrespective of its colour or taste which were prime considerations in Vaastushastra. The criteria of Vaastushastra are not at all worth today.

The Vaastu experts even have some opinion about the parking space. The idea of parking space might not have been there at all while Vaastushastra was developed in ancient period. But the experts say that parking should be either in east or northwest or the north of the plot. All these conditions apparently are quite foolish. The parking space is generally determined by the availability of the space and number of vehicles and their reach on the road and not by directions, heights and slopes.

In spite of all these absurdities the people still fall prey to Vaastu experts. Probably the experts' aggressive marketing may be influencing their decisions or customers' predicaments. The talk of death of one's child, loss of wealth, incurable disease, being lost in debts, theft, accidents, calamity etc are such terrifying things, usually uttered by Vaastu experts, make listeners to take corrective action to their dwellings and spend the money. If Vaastu experts feel that customers is hesitant to spend the money as per their demand, the new breed of Vaastu experts have solutions even for this too. There will be some compromised solution and thus expert will extract money up to the last rupee. Nowadays they combine Vaastushastra of Indian origin with Feng Shui of China and suggest some methodologies to balance the 'energy'. For compensating the energy, they may suggest to place the tortoise (black!) a symbol of safety, long life and intellect, some photo frames, chimes etc thus swindling the customers. Earlier it was thought that Vaastushastra and Feng Shui are competing with each other to claim success. But nowadays there is a holistic approach, thanks to globalization of superstitions!

The author had written open letter to the Vaastu experts and narrates his bitter experience of restructuring his own house as per Vaastu dictates to remove Vaastu Doshas. He lists these Doshas and what actions he took to reduce their ill effects. He even performed Navachandi Yagnya, started wearing Pushkaraj stone and a coral and made rings out of them to wear on fingers. But finally nothing good came out of all these. He concludes that these Vaastu professionals exploit the vulnerability and helplessness, the problems and misfortunes, the greed and temptations of gullible people constantly threatening them with dire consequences of not following their recommendations.

There are number of cartoons and quotations interspersed between the pages and are quite interesting.   On the back cover of the book the author had given the full text of the declaration of scientists on the illusory Vaastushastra which was signed by Dr. Jayant Narlikar. This is also a worth reading material. 

Monday, 13 June 2011

Wide-ranging Questions about India: Review of "Exasperating Essays"

Book Review: 

Exasperating Essays: Exercises in the Dialectical Method
D. D. Kosambi

Prabhakar Nanawaty  (pkn.ans@gmail.com )

"The whole value of Marxism seems to me to be in the absence of dogmatism, mode of approach, and in the attitude to action… The success or failures of the Russian social experiments do not directly affect the validity of the Marxian theory."

-Jawaharlal Nehru, Autobiography

In fact these words were written long before the fall of communist regime in USSR and Jawaharlal Nehru gave a fitting reply to critics of Marxism. However while reading Exasperating Essays: Exercises in the Dialectical Method written by D.D. Kosambi, a scholar, historian and a mathematician, one will understand what misconceptions the elite Indian society had about various aspects of social life in general and Marxism in particular. In fact D.D. Kosambi took mammoth task to air his views on aspects like Is leadership necessary? Need the individual do nothing because all mass changes are inevitable? Is India really headed towards socialism? Is there a powerful class in India that has ideas contrary to those of our leaders and planning commission? Are the Chinese on the way to socialism? What is meant by freedom of science and of the scientist?  Is the 'inner voice' always a safe guide?  Why did Buddhism, the most benign of religions fade away from its own country? What is the significance of the 1857 revolt? Is Sanskrit literature free from class bias? Can the factors that impede World Peace be subjugated? 

DD Kosambi
Professor D.D. Kosambi was one of the best-known scientists of our country endowed with a truly renaissance versatility. Shunning the limelight of publicity, he made outstanding contribution in various fields of knowledge, which included mathematics, statistics, Numismatics, Indology, history as well as contemporary socio – political problems. The book under review is a collection of wide ranging essays written during the years 1939 to 1957. As stated in the introduction written by D.D. Kosambi himself, these essays (and a short story "The Kanpur Road") still continue to attract studious readers. This introduction tries to clarify the philosophical objections raised by Indian official Marxists (OM). In this connection Dr Savyasachi Bhattacharya, Chairman of the Indian Council of Historical Research and a former Professor at Jawaharlal Nehru University, states that “Indian Official Marxists hereafter called OM” were often displeased with him but he could not but protest their “theological emphasis on the inviolable sanctity of the current party line, or irrelevant quotations from the classics.” In using Marxist method in his own lights, in his effort to construe the civilization in India, in the convergences and divergences between his approach and the nationalist discourse of civilization, D.D. Kosambi has left much for us to try and understand and evaluate. There is a feeling that Marxism has become obsolete in 19th century itself. But D.D. Kosambi compares Marxism with scientific achievements of that era and states that the achievements and Marxism will never become obsolete in any sense.

The author refers to the analogy of crystallization to explain the position of leadership in a social movement. He feels that the entire process of transformation with very little scope for super-saturation should be a natural process and its aftermath. He makes this statement while explaining why the communist revolution was successful in Russia but failed in Germany. He attributes this to leadership of Lenin, though he may not have lead the whole movement alone, but he was a great link in the chain. In religious leadership though one cannot predict about theological understanding of masses, the leadership knows how to stand firm during social unrest. In fact the author quotes the example of Mahatma Gandhi. In 1930, when Satyagrah got out of hand, he discovered the need for the uplift of Dalits and whole movement was sidetracked.

While reviewing the book Discovery of India written by Jawaharlal Nehru while he was in prison, the author appreciates the efforts taken by Nehru to put Indian History in broader perspective. However he feels that the book could not be recommended to the general reader, though Prof Kosambi admires the work of Nehru. Prof Kosambi is perplexed on the statements made on racism and casteism prevailing in India. The author analyses the mindset of bourgeoisie settled in South Africa, which typically wants equality with the Whites but not with Negroes. Though the equations might have changed in due course of time; however one can trace the remnants of bourgeoisie mentality in day-to-day affairs even now. In fact Prof Kosambi in a prophetic manner predicts that though history had thrust upon Nehru mantle of leadership, the strong and powerfully organized middle class will cleverly exploit him for its own purpose and Nehru's orientation towards Marxism will be bound to change.


In the essay on 'The Class Structure of India', the author quotes extensively Marx who predicted that the British bourgeoisie would never allow the Indians to reap the fruits of the progress. The author traces the events leading to decline of feudalism in India and how the technological progress metamorphosised the society. In fact hunger, unemployment, epidemic diseases have become permanent and massive features of Indian society in spite of elimination of older property forms and replacing them with vast class of landless farm laborers with no hope of massive industrialization. In reality, with active support of great Indian middle class the Government itself became the biggest capitalist, the main banker, the greatest employer and ultimate refuge of intelligentsia.

According to the author, the greed and avarice of pro-capitalists appears to be one of the reasons for this state of affairs and poor conditions. He finds that civilized moneymakers of advanced capitalist countries are satisfied with 5 % profit margin on their turnover; contrary to this the Indian capitalists' profit range is anywhere between 20 % to 50 %. Indian bourgeoisie had appeared last on the capitalist stage whereas other capitalists have almost abandoned the exploitation and adopted welfare means to satisfy the working class. As such the author suggests that India will be in a position if it adopts socialism. However he was afraid of socialism turning into fascism by empowering a leader to dictate the terms.

It is quite surprising to know that the author, in 1957 itself, predicted that China will be far ahead of any other countries due to its policies and implementation methodologies. According to him the China made progress due to its correct social approach. In fact the author compares India with China and points out at the differences in the mindsets of the population at large. For example, birth control propaganda catches on very quickly in China since Chinese know that in their old age they will be comfortable and looked after by the State even when they are childless. It is not true in India.

In the essay on 'Science and Freedom', the author criticizes heavily the scientists who think freedom means to do whatever they like while being paid by Universities, business houses or governments. In fact the author reminds them that science is no longer 'independent' as it was in its infant stage. Scientists are no more harmless who are toying with toxic chemicals, nuclear materials and complex gadgetries. They are, in fact, part of the society and they don't need any special treatment for their services. There is a well-defined social structure and there is a social necessity for scientists too. The author emphasizes that science is not mere accumulation of experimental data; the data should settle some disputed theory and should have some relation with production. Prof Kosambi feels that the science need not be the creation of gifted individuals. In fact, gifted individuals are there in every age and in every field right from the inception of society. There is nothing great about these individuals since they are the product of the environment in which they are growing.

Like any other thinker and scholar Prof Kosambi too had the curiosity to solve the mystery behind the death of Socrates.  He discusses this issue from democratic angle and makes certain severe comments on the social circumstances of that time under which he was forced to drink the poison.

In the chapter 'The Decline of Buddhism in India', the author pinpoints the reasons for the fall of Buddhism in India. According to him, though the Buddhism owed its initial success since it fulfilled social need of that era, it started deviating from the principles it had set. During the course of time, Buddhism became uneconomic beyond the reach of common man; monasteries became rich, the inmates were pampered, and monks started behaving like Vedic Brahmins. Buddha became 'Chakravarti'. The real damage came from within the practitioners and in fact there was a class distinction among Buddhist scholars, which ultimately lead the religion to decline in India.

The author had devoted a full chapter on the great Sanskrit poet, Bhartrihari, quoting the verses in original and their relevance as a great poet of ancient era.  As a true democrat, the author once again takes the issue in the essay 'Imperialism and Peace'. According to him, peace and democracy are two sides of the same coin and one cannot sustain without the other. No one should claim to be another's master whether by divine right, the right of birth, the right of armed conquest, or the right as a rich. Such rights are acquired by fraudulent means and violence against the vast majority of the people and by destroying truth and justice. The imperialism thrives on the profits and this profit benefits a few monopolists.

While concluding we may quote Dr. Sabyasachi Bhattacharya in verbatim "In posing such wide-ranging questions about the civilization in India, Kosambi differed from the general run of academic historians of his times for they rarely engaged in the discourse of civilizations. He was swimming against the current. The specialized and fragmented view in the academic historians’ professional writings did not usually add up to that vision of totality that the notion of civilization demands. The fact that Kosambi was never given his due by them in his lifetime can be, arguably, ascribed to their disdain for a non-professional who was not only an avowed Marxist, but also given to talking about a dubious entity called ‘civilization.’" 

Exasperating Essays: Exercises in the Dialectical Method
D. D. Kosambi
Published by Sri R.P. Nene, Pune 411030 (1986)
Price Rs 15,  pp 99 

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More