B Premanand
No religion would be accepted by people unless the gods of these religions are shown to have supernatural powers. Their faith in god is not because they love god, but because they have been made to believe that god is ail-powerful. Though it is argued that faith in god turns people from materialism to spirituality, it is obvious that the faith is for material gains - here and in the hereafter. Everything one does in the guise of spirituality, even sacrifices, is for a better tomorrow. The highest aspiration of the people is Moksha, or for the Atma (Soul) to become one with the Paramatma (Universal soul), i.e. to become one with god - to become god, or the omnipotent, omniscient and omnipresent god.
Having
been assured that my answer was not going to upset her, I gave her my truthful
opinion that the miracles of Jesus Christ as narrated in the Bible are false.
No religion would be accepted by people unless the gods of these religions are shown to have supernatural powers. Their faith in god is not because they love god, but because they have been made to believe that god is ail-powerful. Though it is argued that faith in god turns people from materialism to spirituality, it is obvious that the faith is for material gains - here and in the hereafter. Everything one does in the guise of spirituality, even sacrifices, is for a better tomorrow. The highest aspiration of the people is Moksha, or for the Atma (Soul) to become one with the Paramatma (Universal soul), i.e. to become one with god - to become god, or the omnipotent, omniscient and omnipresent god.
Religion
has not been able to help humanity achieve this object. But it knows how to
exploit them. Science and scientific temper alone can help fulfill the
aspirations of humanity for a better, finer life on earth.
Let us
now look at the miracles of each surviving religion and find out whether they
are miracles.
Judaism
In the
Old Testament, Moses is said to have performed several miracles. One was transforming his rod into a snake and
then back again to a rod.
Experiment - 34
Props: One
snake.
Method:
This trick was performed long before Moses performed it. The two ends of a
snake, the tail and mouth-end, are held in two hands and the reptile pulled
straight. Strong pressure in the centre of the head with the thumb and the
pointing finger held on both sides makes the snake stiff. It cannot move even
after lowering the tail-end to the floor. It looks like a rod. To make it crawl
again let free the hand gripping the tail part and shake the snake and throw it
on the ground; within a few minutes it will regain its moving power and crawl
away.
Christianity
New Testament:
In a
radio interview in the United
States , I was confronted by a Catholic woman
on the phone. In the United
States , radio interviews are very different
from here. Here one interviewer asks questions, but there people interested in
the subject can turn up at the radio station to ask any question pertaining to
the subject. Even other people hearing the interviews in their homes, can ask
any questions over a phone which has to be answered by the person being interviewed.
If he is unable to answer, he is greeted with loud jeering and hooting.
During
my interview the woman phoned up and asked "Mr. Premanand, what you tell
about the miracles of the Indian godmen are true. They are real frauds. Now
tell us your opinion of the miracles of Jesus Christ."
I tried
to evade the question by answering that "I was not living two thousand
years ago when Jesus was said to be alive, please ask me questions of what is
happening today."
She
again asked me if I had read the Bible to which I answered in the affirmative.
I even told her that I can talk and debate on the Bible.
Then
her question was as to what I thought of the miracles said to have been
performed by Jesus Christ in the New Testament.
I asked
her whether she wanted an evasive answer or a truthful opinion, and whether my
answer would upset her.
She
answered me that Christians show the other cheek when they are slapped on one,
and they never get emotionally upset.
B Premanand |
Instantly
she burst out on the phone, "who brought this bastard to the United States ?"
I was shocked by her anger.
I had
to keep my emotion under control. I told her that the word "bastard"
is a divine word found only in holy scriptures and not in the dictionary of the
rationalists as they know that they are born to parents, and even if they may
not know, or have proof as to who those parents are, they are born out of union
between a male and a female with the fusion of sperm and ova. So nobody can be
a bastard. The only person who is said to have been without a parent is god. So
she must not use this divine word on me.
This
answer infuriated her further and she spat out in anger. "Hang this
bastard!"
I
replied to her coolly that I didn't mind being hanged. But I would like to ask
her a question before being hanged. "Do you really believe in god, Jesus
Christ and the Holy Ghost?"
Her
answer was "Yes, fully."
I asked
her whether she had read chapter ten of the Holy Bible St. Mathew wherein Jesus
Christ sends his twelve apostles to the people to perform all the miracles said
to have been done by Christ.
But
they failed in their attempts and questioned Christ why they failed and his
answer was "because of your unbelief. If you have faith as a grain of
mustard seed, ye shall say unto this mountain, Remove hence to yonder place,
and it shall remove: and nothing shall be impossible unto you." (St.
Mathew Chapter 17, No.19).
As she
had said that she had full faith in the trinity, I would be happy, if she hangs
me to death and resurrects me like the resurrection of Lazarus when the first
thing I would do would be to become a Christian and believe in Christ.
"Before you kill me, let us go to a hospital where we can find a dead body
and you resurrect it and prove that you really believe in god, Jesus Christ and
the Holy Ghost." She was silenced and I got the applause.
Now let
us take some miracles said to have been performed by Jesus Christ.
Experiment: 35
Effect:
Transformation of water to wine.
This incident is narrated in St.
John Chapter 2, I to II. Jesus Christ is said to have attended a marriage in
Cana of Galilee. There was not enough wine for all. Christ asked people to
bring water. It was brought and he asked them to pour the water in six stone
jars kept there. The water in the six stone jars was transformed into wine. If
I was there at the time I would surely have asked why the water had to be
poured into the six stone jars. If he really could transform water into wine,
it could as well be transformed in the vessel used for bringing water.
Props:
- One long tumbler, one short tumbler which goes into
the first tumbler with its rim a little projected outside.
- Another
aluminium tumbler which if reversed over the two tumblers the short
tumbler would get stuck in it and would not be visible.
- Water and wine.
Method:
Fill the long tumbler with wine and place the short tumbler in it. Take the
long tumbler in the left hand, pour water and then reverse the aluminium
tumbler over it and press. Move your hands over the closed tumbler, remove the
aluminium tumbler lid and keep it slowly on the table hiding the bottom from
the audience. Distribute the wine.
When
the aluminium tumbler is placed on the long tumbler and pressed, the short
tumbler with water gets stuck in it while in the long tumbler there is already
wine.
Declaring
that he is the incarnation of all gods including Jesus Christ, Satya Sai Baba
claims to have transformed water into nectar and even petrol and diesel. If he
really had powers why does he do this transformation in his own vessel? If I
was there two thousand years ago I would have certainly requested Jesus to
transform water in a well into wine so that any time people could go to the
well and draw the wine. Then only would I concede that Christ had real powers.
This is what I ask the present day god men like Satya Sai Baba. Instead of
transforming water into nectar or petrol in his own pots or tins, let him
transform a well or tank into nectar or petrol. Then we will have to accept his
powers. Even in nature crude oil can only be tapped from an oil well. But if a
water well can produce petrol, our country would not need to put up
petro-chemical plants. It is a pity that no god man has yet done so in the
history of miracles.
[Here is another method to "transform water to wine". Here the "transformed" water looks like wine]