Showing posts with label Vinayak Savarkar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Vinayak Savarkar. Show all posts

Thursday, 16 July 2015

Manufacturing and Undermining National Icons: RSS Style

Ram Puniyani

Many a social and political processes related to projection of some icons and undermining of the others have intensified during last few years. Even during the last regime of NDA led BJP rule from 1998, Savakar’s portrait was unveiled in the Parliament. At one level the game of undermining some icons and projecting icons is a part of various political streams and RSS seems to be the past master in the same. One recalls its machinery has been putting forward some names. bypassing others and undermining some others. Since the time Modi has come to power as Prime Minister Mahatma Gandhi’s assassin Nathuram Godse is being upheld by many from RSS combine. One BJP MP called him a patriot and other BJP MP said that Godse chose the wrong target, instead of Gandhi; he should have chosen Nehru as his target. There are demands from various quarters to allot land for raising his statues in different places.

Times and over again Sardar Patel is projected vis a vis Nehru. In one of the speeches Modi said Patel should have been the first Prime minister of India instead of Nehru. Various ‘word of mouth’ propaganda to denigrate Nehru has been the consistent activity of many. Again to undermine Nehru Modi said something which was not true. He said that Nehru did not attend the funeral of Sardar Patel. This again is a blatant lie. As far as Mahatma Gandhi is concerned this present ruling dispensation has projected him but only for the values of cleanliness. One knows that the stature of Mahatma is such that even those who do not believe in his inclusive nationalism have also to pay obeisance to him at home as well as abroad. To circumvent this problem while the core essence of Gandhi’s struggle for Hindu Muslim unity is sidelined, the teachings of the Mahatma for National Integration are give a go bye and he is projected for only for swachhta abhiyan (cleanliness drive).

Currently major concerted efforts are being made to highlight Ambedkar. There are statements that Ambedkar and Hedgewars’ (The founder and first supreme leader of RSS) values were similar, both were against untouchability for example. RSS mouthpiece Organiser (English) and Panchjanya (Hindi) have come out with the special supplements on the life of Ambedkar, presenting his teachings in a distorted manner to create the illusion that there was similarity between the teachings of RSS ideology of HIndutva and Ambedkars values. Ambedkar had contributed in various ways for social justice and democratic values and struggle for annihilation of caste was the foremost amongst the movements launched by him.  Incidentally one need to recall that in contrast to Ambedkars Annihilation of caste, RSS has floated and organization called ‘Samajik Samrasta Manch’ (Social Harmony Forum) which works for bringing harmony between castes without challenging the very existence of caste, which was the prime motive of Ambedkar.

One can see two trends in the exercise being done by the RSS combine. On one hand since RSS never participated in the freedom struggle as an organization, it has no icon to present as a freedom fighter. This is why they have to stretch their myth making to project Savarkar as being a freedom fighter. The case of Savarkar is peculiar. He was initially working against the British rule but after he was jailed in Andaman’s, he buckled under pressure and turned from anti British revolutionary to the one who apologized to British and later never participated in any anti British agitation. That’s all RSS combine has to show for their participation in freedom struggle. Even Savarkar was not the part of RSS, but ideologically Savarkar and RSS both held Hindutva, Hindu nation as their goals.

As many in the RSS combine revere Godse, he always slips in as the major icon for them. Godse was initially trained in RSS Shakhas and later he went onto become the Secretary of Pune Branch of Hindu Mahasabha. Since many BJP leaders have background in RSS shakhas, and are on same page as Godse as far as Hindu Nationalism is concerned, they do come out to praise Godse. These two, Savarkar and Godse are projected to show their allegiance to the ideology of Hindu nationalism in contrast to Indian nationalism, which is the core part of Indian Constitution. This is necessary for them as they are projecting themselves as biggest nationalists unmindful of the fact that their nationalism is Hindu Nationalism and not Indian Nationalism. They want to derive legitimacy from Savarkars’ initial anti British role. The later part of Savarkar where he kept aloof from freedom movements is the exact way in which RSS also kept aloof from freedom movement.

At another level they want to contrast Patel with Nehru. It is meant to undermine Nehru. Patel and Nehru, both were close allies on most of the issues related to freedom movement, both were the major followers of Gandhi, who was their mentor and they were collaborating with each other in the national movement and later as part of the first Cabinet of Independent India. RSS combine cannot swallow the uncompromising stand taken by Nehru during his long years of Prime Minister-ship on the issues of secularism and his long association with these principles in a forthright way so they want to contrast him with Patel, who was also a deeply secular person.

At another level there are some in-house icons which are propped up or are undermined. RSS second Sarsanghchalak Golwalkar has been a great influence on generations of RSS workers. His book, ‘We or Nationhood defined’, shaped the thought process of many of them. He went to the extent of upholding Hitler’s method and type of nationalism expounded by him. His book used to be available in RSS shops for long time. One of his quotes sums up the RSS ideology very well, writes Golwalkar “German national pride has now become the topic of the day. To keep up the purity of nation and its culture, Germany shocked the world by her purging the country of semitic races-The Jews. National pride at its highest has been manifested here. Germany has also shown how neigh impossible it is for races and cultures, having differences going to the root, to be assimilated into one united whole, a good lesson for us in Hindustan to learn and profit by. (We or Our nationhood Defined P. 27, Nagpur 1938). From more than a decade ago RSS started feeling embarrassed about this due to electoral-political compulsions and started making arguments that this book was not written by Golwalkar. It was withdrawn from market. Here electoral expediency shaped their decision.

At another level they have been projecting Deendayal Upadhayay as the major figure. Deendayal Upadhdyay is the ideologue who had coined “integral humanism’ as the concept, this essentially talks about upholding status quo of social relations of caste in particular. This is done to give a subtle message of deeper agenda of the RSS politics. The play with the icons goes with the long term program of the cultural and social manipulation for building a society with the hegemony of Hindutva politics, a politics which derives its name from a religion but at core is the political agenda of elite of the Hindu society, irrespective of the fact that some from the lower strata of society are also co-opted for this political agenda. It’s due to this that RSS focuses a lot on propagating the culture of a variety which is sectarian and backward looking, the agenda of Hindu Nationalism.

Thursday, 6 September 2012

Was Veer Savarkar Really “Veer”?


R.A Jahagirdar

For generations the Hindutvavadis have venerated Vinayak Sawarkar as Veer Savarkar. The writings of Savarkar, especially in Marathi, show great valour and heroic sentiments. In language that is both beautiful and brave, the writings of Savarkar - in prose and poetry - display heroic qualities but of Hinduism. Savarkar wrote an essay, “Hindutva” (Hinduness) in which he tells us who are really Hindus. Merely by birth in India, one does not become a Hindu. Hindu is one, says Savarkar, whose land of worship (“Punya Bhumi”) is India; whose history, trials or tribulations are centred around in Hindustan. If one looks towards Mecca or Jerusalem for religious inspiration, he cannot be a Hindu as defined by Savarkar. Thus Muslims and Christians whose basic holy places are outside India are not and cannot be called Hindus. The Hindutva idea is alien to them. This is in sum, Savarkar’s idea of Hindutva – a term which is not the same as Hinduism. Buddhists and Jains whose religions are not Hindu are yet embraced by Hindutva. It is almost a mystical concept.

Savarkars's statue in front of
Cellular Jail, Port Blair installed during
BJP rule in Delhi
(Date of photograph: 15 August 2012)
Savarkar did not and could not foresee Hindu Diaspora or even Muslim Diaspora. Large numbers of Hindus have migrated to U.S.A. and have acquired citizenship of America. Their ethos – is it included in Hindutva? The largest numbers of Buddhists are outside India in several East Asian countries. Can we say that they must display Hindutva? It will be an act of treason if they love India to the exclusion of the countries whose citizens they are. In his book “First War of Indian Independence” (which is about 1857) Savarkar speaks of joint Hindu-Muslim revolt. But that was long before the birth of Hindutva in Savarkar’s mind.

Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, later also known as Tatyasaheb Savarkar, was born in 1883 in a town called Bhagur in Nasik District of Maharashtra. Even his biographers do not speak of his brilliance as a student. But his later writings, both prose and poetry, display of unusual command of Marathi language which continues to inspire Maharashtrians. It may be stated incidentally that on an occasion in England where he had gone for studies he wrote a poem asking the ocean “to take me to my motherland”. In song frame it has been sung by Mangeshkar siblings and it has become immortal in Maharashtra. In the song he tells, among other things, that mother’s cottage is better than a palace.

It has been recorded that once in his student days he pelted stones at a mosque in his town. He exhibited anti-Muslim feelings, even in his college days. He went to college in Pune. He organized groups of Hindus whom he inspired to be good and strong Hindus.

With the help of one Pandit Shyamji Krishna Verma, a strong believer in Hinduism, then resident of London, Savarkar went to England for education. An activist of “Abhinav Bharat”, a revolutionary organization for freedom of India, Savarkar took part in several activities. Dhananjay Keer mentions that he was, in 1908, convicted for outraging the modesty of an English girl and spent four months in jail as a consequence. Savarkar also displayed strong patriotism inasmuch as he studied Mazzini and translated one book on Mazzini which came to be published in Nasik and enjoyed an uncommon popularity among Maharashtrians. That, Savarkar was a patriot is not disputed.

Madan Lal Dingra was hanged for assassinating Sir William Carzon Wylie who was the eye and brain of India House. Savarkar had inspired Dingra to do the act. Savarkar had also sent pistols clandestinely and one of them was found to have killed A.M.T. Jackson, the Collector of Nasik. The pistol which killed Jackson was traced to Savarkar who was arrested in London under Fugitives Act and brought to India. I have refrained from describing the activities of Savarkar in England. Suffice it to say that those activities show his patriotism and intelligence. One thing, however, must be noted. It was never Savarkar’s hand that pulled the trigger at any time. He inspired but never acted. While Savarkar was being brought to India in a ship, he jumped in the sea through a port hole. That was in France. However, he was captured and brought back. This was the only physical act of Savarkar in the cause of freedom. What he did was undoubtedly a daring act.

Ultimately he was tried, among others, for the murder of Jackson and sentenced to life imprisonment. Also in another case he was sentenced to life imprisonment. Those days, life imprisonment meant 25 years which in Savarkar’s case meant 50 years. It was a fearful prospect which would have broken any man. If it broke the courage of Savarkar, one cannot blame him.

This is where the act of so-called bravery of the person begins. He was transported to Andaman Island to serve his sentence in the awful cellular jail. This was regarded, among the Indians, as “Kalapani”. It was the forced destination of hardened criminals.

Hard physical labour awaited Savarkar. He was received at Port Blair of Andaman on July 4, 1911. He was 28 years old. Within two years thereafter, Sir Reginald Craddock, Home Member Viceroy’s Executive Council, met him. Sir Reginald’s note recorded Savarkar’s plea for mercy. On November 14, 1913, Savarkar had written to the Government: “I am ready to serve the Government they like … Where else can the prodigal son return but to the parental doors of the Government?” (Emphasis mine). In reply to a question in the Legislative Council on March 22, 1920, the Home Member, Sir William Vincent said: “Two Petitions were received from Vinayak Damodar Savarkar – one in 1914 and another in 1917 – through the Superintendent, Port Blair. In the former he offered his services to the governmentduring the war in any capacity and prayed that general amnesty be granted to all political prisoners. The second Petition was confined to the latter proposal. In the Petition dated November 23, 1913, he wrote: “In the end, I remind your honour to be good as to go through the Petition for clemency that I had sent in 1911 and to sanction it for being forwarded to the Indian Government”. He had in the same letter said: “Therefore the Government in their manifold beneficence and mercy release me, I for one cannot be the staunchest advocate of progress and loyalty to the English which is the foremost condition of that progress.” The Government which he had decided not to serve became a Government of beneficence and mercy. The rebel became a person of loyalty. Continuing further he said: “Moreover my conversion to the Constitutional line would bring back all those misguided young men in India and abroad who were once looking at me as their guide.”

“Veer” means, brave, hero, gallant, warrior as per Sanskrit and Marathi dictitionaries. This Veer gave apologies as many as five times.

After being brought back to India, Savarkar was lodged in Yaravada Jail. It was when he was in this jail that he was to be conditionally released. On January 6, 1924, he was released subject to certain conditions. Two of them were as follows:

1. Savarkar shall reside in Ratnagiri district and shall not go beyond the limits of that district without the permission of Government or in case of emergency of the District Magistrate.

2. He will not engage privately or publicly in any manner of political activities without the consent of Government for a period of five years, such restrictions being renewable at the discretion of Government at the expiry of the said period.

The option to renew the terms was with Government and not with Savarkar who accepted the conditions.

In 1937 Congress formed in Bombay. It was the same Congress upon whom Savarkar had heaped abuses all along. The Government, in their “beneficence and mercy” relaxed the conditions of detention. Savarkar was free. His followers were naturally jubilant.

But on April 4, 1950 Savarkar was arrested, unjustifiably, under Public Security Measures Act (law of detention). A habeas corpus Petition was filed by Savarkar’s son, Vishwas, and it was heard by a Bench of Chief Justice Chagla and Justice Gajendragadkar. After taking instruction from the Government, the Advocate General, C.K. Daftary, who was prosecuting Counsel in Gandhi murder case, informed the Court that the Government would release Savarkar if he gave an undertaking that he would not participate in politics. Undertaking was given by Savarkar’s Advocate on his behalf and the Court ordered the release on that undertaking. This was the last condition which Savarkar accepted.

How did he came to be known as Veer Savarkar? Who gave him that title? I am not able to find in any published literature an answer to these questions. However, personal inquiries made by me have revealed that Mrs. Bhapatkar, the editor of “Bhala”, a Marathi periodical, dubbed Savarkar as Veer. Somewhere on the road, the word “Swatantrya” was added and thus Savarkar became Swatantrya Veer Savarkar” – Freedom Fighter Savarkar who did not do anything for the country after 1913 till his death in 1966.

Nelson Mandela spent twenty three years in jail and refused to admit that he would not take part in politics. Still we do not call him Swatantrya Veer.

I have not dealt with other aspects of Savarkar’s life except his apologies and undertakings which are relevant to the title of Swatantrya Veer. It must be admitted that large number of Maharashtrians, especially Brahmins, adored him. In Mumbai when Sangha Pariwar was in power in Municipal Corporation, a road was named after him. That road is one of the longest roads in Mumbai and it runs into 3 postal districts. On this road has been erected, probably the biggest memorial in India, named after Savarkar.

During the time when Manohar Joshi was the Speaker, an oil portrait of Savarkar was unveiled in the Central Hall of the Parliament, but Mahatma Gandhi’s statue sits in the open braving the sun and winds.

Courtesy: Collected Works of Justice R.A. Jahagirdar (1927-2011) published by Rationalist Foundation, Pune, the ebook version of which can be downloaded at http://www.arvindguptatoys.com/


Saturday, 5 May 2012

Savarkar: Was He a Rationalist?


R.A. Jahagirdar 

We publish this essay by Justice RA Jahagirdahr (1927-2011) on the Hindutva ideologue Vinayak Damodar Savarkar  in the context of the 8th National Conference of Federation of Indian Rationalist Associations (FIRA) held in Nagapur on 11-12 February 2012. The official souvenir brought out during the conference had a photograph of Vinayak Savarkar with the astonishing remark that the rationalists cannot forget his contributions to humanity. This attempt to put this Hindutva ideologue, who in fact coined the word “Hindutva”, on a rationalist pedestal is nothing but reprehensible. Despite the enormous quantity of literature available today conclusively establishing that Savarkar was a rabid Hindu communalist, it is surprising that some ‘rationalists’ still project Savarkar as their leader. What was still more surprising was that the entire FIRA leadership did not make even a murmur against this crude attempt on the part of the local host (Akhil Bharatiya Andhashraddha Nirmoolan Samiti) of the conference to use the FIRA platform to project their ideology.  It is in this background that we publish this essay by the late Justice RA Jahagirdhar (1927-2011). Courtesy: Collected Works of Justice R.A. Jahagirdar (Retd) (1927-2011) published by Rationalist Foundation, Pune. The book can be downloaded at http://www.arvindguptatoys.com/


It is generally be1ieved that Savarkar was a rationalist, despite his belief in Hindutva. He advised the general public of India, more particularly Hindus that Vedas, Upanishads and Puranas are good literature but not guides. They should be kept in the cupboard as pieces to look good. Even Bhagwad Gita allegedly dictated by Lord Krishna was a piece of literature and only expounded what he regarded as a good guide. It described four phases of man and we are free to follow any one as the pathway to God. In short, he did not believe in the supernatural.

Vinayak Savarkar
On these and other grounds Maharashtra Andhashraddha Nirmoolan Samiti has hailed him as a great social reformer of Maharashtra. If one reads the piece on Savarkar, he is in fact, regarded as a rationalist of Maharashtra on par with Gadge Maharaj, who tried to teach people to clean Maharashtra - even personally sweeping the land and bylanes of the city and villages. He in his own language admonished the people to lead a personal good life. Gadge Maharaj never invoked God for the social reform he preached and in fact did not personally practice any rituals. He took a broom in his hand and set an example of how and why the streets and public places be swept.

This was not the rationalism of Savarkar. Though Savarkar advocated that meat prohibited for the high caste Hindu, should be eaten by them. No food was prohibited by Savarkar. Savarkar’s advocacy that Hindus should eat meat was based upon the belief that meat has strength. But it was a myth, because he forgot that an elephant, though so huge was strictly vegetarian and if an occasion was available to it, it could also lift a lion (who was a strict nonvegetarian) with his trunk and injure or kill it. The lion could attack and kill an elephant more because of his agility and mobility. But Savarkar was right in the absurdity of the ban on meat. Meat was a taboo to orthodox Hindus because it was animal food. No food was prohibited, according to Savarkar. Food should he chosen on the basis of its nutritional value and not on the basis of religious edicts. He might even have ridiculed the Muslims and Jews for prohibiting eating of pork because the people of Kodagu (Coorg in English) eat it as a regular food item. To Americans, English and even Europeans, no food is prohibited. Africans also eat almost any food, scarcely barring some. Despite being born in a Chitpawan Hindu family (a sect of Hindus), Savarkar advocated or at least did not prohibit eating meat. But should he be regarded as a rationalist for this? It would be a very narrow conception. Hitler was a vegetarian. Akbar was a vegetarian.

A group photo of people accused in the Mahatma Gandhi's murder case. 
Standing: Shankar Kistaiya, Gopal Godse, Madanlal Pahwa, Digambar Badge. 
Sitting: Narayan Apte, Vinayak D. Savarkar, Nathuram Godse, Vishnu Karkare
In this connection, it is interesting to note that M.N. Roy, the great rationalist, persuaded Virendra Chattopadhyaya to eat beef in Germany. Roy told Chattopadhyaya that Hindus forbade eating cow’s meat (beef), in India, not in Germany. So one can safely say that, Savarkar was a rationalist in matters of food.

That is not all. Because Savarkar said although the Vedas and Upanishadas are Hindu scriptures, no one reads them. Therefore, it is said that Savarkar was a rationalist. Normally if a person’s source of knowledge is articles in a book, he is not a rationalist. Similarly, one who regards a person or a book holy can never be a rationalist.

It is perfectly in order that a rationalist or even a common man should reject Vedas and Upanishads. Puranas do not teach any moral lesson. Shambhuk episode, Wali incident, Sita’s totally unjust Agnipariksha and some other features make Ramayana unacceptable. Mahabharat is still worse. There are many persons in Mahabharat who were not born legitimately. Of course, this is imagination but the bulk of Hindu population believes in them, as they are entertaining. Due to their entertainment value and because of technical and other reasons they attracted audiences on T.V. on Sunday mornings. But Bible was a failure in this predominantly Hindu kingdom. One can speculate how a serialization of Quran would fare. Of course, the rationalists regard them as myths. The three books mentioned are no doubt figments of imagination for the rationalists. It is not mentioned that Savarkar condemned these as wrong on ethical grounds or any of the Puranas on any other ground. Rationalism as an appellation can hardly be applied. Ramayana, Mahabharata are good entertainment stories, as Arabian Nights but no human being should and can use them for self edification. There are so many irrational propositions in them, which no rationalist can accept. Puranas come in the same category. Probably they were composed in the third or fourth century to arrest Buddhism and Lokayat. Upanishads are a different story. Though they are attached to Vedas, they contain theoretical discussion and not one of them has canvassed that God exists. Even Kathopanishad and Brihadaranyak Upanishads do not advance the theory of theism. A rationalist cannot believe the Vedas. Rigved and Yajurved contain at places such unrefined passages which are not brought to the notice of the believers. Even Atharvaveda and Sam Veda do not contain any educational material. Rationalists study them but by no stretch of imagination can accept them. Savarkar in his voluminous writings examines them but does not condemn them. As such, he might be a normal Hindu but definitely not a rationalist.

The literature to which I have made reference so far does not contain any law that might have governed the Hindus. Sometimes as Ram Shastri Prabhune says, they might have been weighed as Hadith; sometimes a story, here or there, attributable to God or Gods might have given guidance or even wrong guidance. For example, Shambuka episode earned for Rama the Sobriquet Purushottam from Agastyamuni, one of the eight Rishis who were the preceptors of Rama. Unfortunately, some of the Hindu kings thought they were following Sanatana dharma by behaving according to these irrational, incoherent and even unjust laws which endorse beheading of Shambuka (a Shudra youth) by Rama. They cannot he called rationalists.

But the book which acted as a law book for Hindus, like Savarkar, was a Smriti called Manusmriti. Even till 1956, the Courts, including Privy Council, accepted the law propounded by Manusmriti as the law of Hindus. It is the most irrational book which should not have seen the light of day. No rationalist could accept the legal propositions that the Hindus were expected to follow. Did Savarkar condemn the book? No, he even praised the book and said the weakness of the Hindus was cause of not following the book. Remember this was before 1956. There is no book in the world which treats the so-called Shudras and women as contemptible and untouchables as inhumanly as Manusmriti. I venture to think that the Hindus believed in Manusmriti and accepted it is the reason why India has not produced a single philosopher after Sankaracharya. There were only Bhaktas like Tukararam, etc. but not thinkers or philosophers. Many of the Bhaktas, it seems, were, schizophrenic. All Bhaktas were not of the same hue. But Hindus accepted all of them with equal reverence.

There is not enough space here to enumerate all the irrationalities of Manusmriti. But it is sufficient to remember that Manusmriti tells us that the woman in her childhood depends upon her parents, in her youth or adulthood on her husband and in her old age on her children. No woman deserves freedom, women’s sensual pleasures must be kept under control, the man is the one to whom the woman adheres, a woman should get a loaf of bread, a seat and ornaments.

There are still more ‘gems’ about woman written in Manusmriti. Remember, though Manusmriti was a Smriti, it was a law, binding upon Hindus. In 1940, Savarkar in his presidential address of Hindu Mahasabha showed his commitment to Manusmriti and said that if the lessons of Manusmriti were learnt, Hindu society will be stronger. Savarkar was bold enough to say that “our Hindu nation shall prove again unconquerable and a conquering race as we proved once (Samagra Savarkar Sangrah, published by Maharashtra Hindu Mahasabha, Pune p. 426.) I must casually mention that Hindu Mahasabha has done a great service by publishing all Savarkar works in 1960 for only Rs. 160/-

Manusmriti further said that:

A) Shudras were born from the feet (of Brahma);
B) God has given only one occupation to Shudra viz. serving the high caste;
C) If a Shudra arrogantly teaches the Brahmin about the latter’s duty, the King shall cause hot oil to be poured in Shudra’s ears;
D) If a Shudra pretends to be of a higher caste, his lips should be branded;
E) No collection of wealth should be made by a Shudra;
F) The son of a Brahniin from a Shudra woman inherits no property.

There are more ‘gems’ like these in Manusmriti which no rational man can endorse. But Savarkar did. Read this in Savarkar’s Samagra Sahitya (original in Hindi).

“Manusmriti is that scripture which is most worshipable after Vedas for our Hindu nation, and which from ancient times has become the basis of our culture, customs, thought and practice. The book for centuries has codified the spiritual and divine march of our nation. Even today, the rules which are followed by crores of Hindus in their lives are based upon Manusmriti. Today Manusmriti is Hindu Law. That is fundamental.” (Emphasis provided.) Savarkar was addressing a joint conference of Hindu Mahasabha and RSS.

Savarkar has a reputation of being the leader and mentor of Hindus. Untouchahility was a part of Hindu Dharma. Ambedkar fought against it all through his life and ultimately embraced Buddhism. No religion or society in the world (except Hindus) has sanctified untouchables. Savarkar was not averse to untouchability, though later he established Patit Pavan Sangh in Ratnagiri. It has never traversed beyond Ratnagiri and Pune. Untouchability is regarded as a curse by all (except Hindu Mahasabha and RSS). Even Mahatma Gandhi condemned it, though he could have been unwilling to exclude them from the Hindu fold. Untouchables were regarded as ati-Shudras but outside the pale of caste-system. Gandhi would have probably accepted them in the Shudra caste.

We have already seen how Manusmriti regarded untouchables. Even the shadow of an untouchable cannot fall upon a Brahmin or in his path. But he made some cosmetic changes to Hindu society. While permitting caste Hindus to dine with untouchables, he emphatically said in 1939 that the Hindu Mahasabha, “will not introduce or support compulsory legislation regarding Temple entry by untouchables, etc. in old temples beyond the limit the non-Hindus are allowed by Custom as in force today.”

Thus, he was not in favour of unqualified entry of Harijans in temples as Ambedkar had launched in Kalaram temple; Kakasaheb Gadgil participated in Parvati in Pune and Senapati Bapat, in general.

On 20th June, Savarkar again guaranteed that the Hindu Mahasabha shall not enforce any legislation regarding the entry of untouchables in the ancient temples or be compelled by law for amending any sacred ancient and moral usage or custom prevailing in those temples. In general, the Mahasabha will not support any legislation, which may be thrust upon it.

While considering the reformist views of the Savarkar brothers, so far as personal law is concerned, let alone a rationalist, was Savarkar even a reformer?

I have already mentioned above that Savarkar never made efforts to ameliorate the condition of untouchables. Though he founded the Patit Pavan Sangh but with Bhagurkars Patit Pavan Sangh untouchables remained untouchables. Hindu Mahasahha as an organisation did nothing for untouchables. Savarkar opposed, as mentioned, the entry of untouchables into temples. Gods of caste Hindu temples were surely, the Gods of untouchables too, but the latter had no access to them. Laxman Shastri clearly advised Gandhi that untouchabilily had no sanction of Shastras. Savarkar never endorsed this view. This is the inhumanism of the rationalist Savarkar.

A couple of matters, not pertaining strictly to rationalism need be mentioned here. He was a Hindu Nationalist believing that Hindustan belonged to Hindus and no one else. Akhand (undivided) has always been the motto of Hindu Mahasabha of which Savarkar was the President. In fact, it was founded by him. Yet, on 15th August, 1943 (four years before partition) he said, “I have no quarrel with Mr. Jinnah’s two nations theory that Hindus and Muslims are two nations. We Hindus are a nation by ourselves and it is a historical fact that Hindus and Muslims are two nations.”

In the same place he mentioned that Hindus would he in the dominant position. Dominant in what, say—more taxes, more posts etc. Savarkar says nothing about it. Rest of the speech is confusing and incoherent and at least needs no examination. A nation is always based upon territory. Muslims, as a nation in Savarkar’s confession, would occupy a territory. Then where is Akhand Hindustan (undivided India)?

At one time Sindh and Bengal had Coalition Ministries. Shyam Prakash Mukherjee (son of Ashutosh) was a minister in the Bengal. Savarkar’s hatred for Congress was so intense that Dhananjay Keer (almost official Biographer) mentions that, “Savarkar had advised the Hindu leaders in the Muslim majority provinces to join Ministries formed by Muslim League (Keer -p.348)

This is the Hinduism or nationalism of Savarkar. That Savarkar was opposed to Quit India movement need not be held against him. Consistent with this view he advised Hindus to join armed forces “not to defeat fascism but to strengthen Hinduism.” In fact, he chided Nehru for opposing fascism for, according to Savarkar, Hitler and Mussolini knew what was best for their countries.

When in Ratnagiri Jail (where he had been transferred), Savarkar wrote his magnum opus Hindutva, wherein he made a distinction between Hindutva and Hinduism. All those who come under the umbrella of Hinduism were Hindus, for according to Savarkar, those whose history, gods, pitrubhumi (father’s home-land) and matrubhumi (mother’s home-land) were within and from this land were Hindus; so defined, Sikhs. Buddhists and Jains were Hindus but not Muslims and Christians. Muslims’ attachment was for Kaba and Mecca, their holy places. Christians looked towards Jerusalem where Jesus was crucified. Their Pitrubhumi was India but their Punyabhumi (land of worship) was abroad, not Hindustan. Therefore, they are not Hindus. Savarkar’s confusion and incoherence are evident here. He equated religion with nation. But see what he says elsewhere that “change of religion leads to change of nationality.”

I have given enough material to show that Savarkar was not a rationalist. He was communal. I do not hold against him that he was acquitted in Gandhi murder case. The government did not appeal against him. Being a lawyer I would say, agreeing with the Supreme Court, that he was doubly innocent.

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More